EDP Processes

Eurostat's objective for government finance statistics (GFS) is to ensure that the government deficit and debt figures published through the so-called 'EDP notifications' are of the highest possible quality and comparability.

Quality assurances are given through the processes described in the Inventory of Eurostat's EDP Processes.

Eurostat’s commitment on Government Finance Statistics

GFS play a key role in EU economic monitoring. They include in particular the data on government debt and deficit reported under the Excessive Deficit Procedure (EDP). On behalf of the Commission, Eurostat is responsible for assessing the quality of the EDP statistics transmitted by EU Member States and for providing the statistics to be used for EDP. It has sole competence on the methodology underlying these statistics.

This methodology is based on the European System of Accounts (ESA), which has the status of an EU Regulation, on Eurostat's Manual of Government Deficit and Debt (MGDD), as well as Eurostat's decisions and guidance notes. This methodology has been elaborated based on a broad consensus in the EU statistical community.

In carrying out its responsibilities, the mission of Eurostat in the field of GFS is to be the guardian of the implementation of the ESA by Member States, whatever the circumstances, and to develop, when necessary, sound interpretations of the ESA, based on advice from the EU statistical community.

Eurostat conducts this mission respecting the principles of equal treatment of Member State countries and of the European Statistics Code of Practice, in particular professional independence, objectivity and impartiality. It maintains a continuous dialogue with all relevant institutions in the EU Member States, and provides bilateral advice for specific past and future transactions.

Eurostat's legal framework

The central legal framework for the production and notification of EDP statistics is Regulation (EU) 479/2009 (details can be accessed under 'Legislation'). Furthermore, in 2011, Eurostat communicated to the European Parliament and the Council a strategy for establishing a robust quality management framework for EU statistics (Communication 2011(211)). The communication was endorsed by the ECOFIN Council of June 2011. It calls for the reinforcement of professional independence in the governance of the European Statistical System through an amended statistical law (Regulation (EU) 223/2009) and a reinforced Code of Practice for European Statistics. It also aims to enhance the quality of EDP statistics, notably by extending the scope of EDP verification to 'upstream' (public accounting) source data. Eurostat has gained investigative powers with a view to reinforcing budgetary surveillance in the euro area (Regulation (EU) 1173/2011).

Scope of Eurostat's verification

In its assessment of the quality of the GFS and EDP statistics transmitted by Member States, Eurostat is committed to verifying:

  • the compliance with ESA accounting rules by the national reporting authorities;
  • the exhaustiveness of the coverage of the general government sector, in particular by means of a register of government controlled entities;
  • the quality of the 'EDP Inventories of Methods, Procedures and Sources' of EU Member States;
  • the reliability, timeliness and consistency of the statistical data;
  • the consistency, sustainability, transparency, documentation and control of the EDP compilation processes within national statistical authorities;
  • the conformity of these processes with the European Statistics Code of Practice and
  • the degree of assurance provided by internal controls and external audits by supreme audit institutions or other external audit bodies of the quality of public accounts used as inputs to the EDP compilation processes.

In order to communicate the results of its assessment as widely as possible, Eurostat is also committed to:

  • publish a bi-annual news release (euro-indicators release) on EU Member States' notifications of deficit and debt;
  • publicly communicate any 'qualified' positions it takes as regards EU Member States' data on deficit and debt by means of 'reservations' and 'amendments' and
  • transparency by maintaining a dedicated GFS website which includes detailed EDP tables, supplementary notes on the notified data, methodological notes, and reports on EDP visits.

It is important to note that Eurostat is not in a position to:

  • certify accounts of individual entities classified into the general government sector of EU Member States;
  • take responsibility in cases of deliberate misreporting by national reporting authorities or other reporting entities when no direct or indirect sources were available to cross check these accounts;
  • take responsibility in cases of errors committed by national reporting authorities or other reporting entities when no direct or indirect sources were available to cross check these accounts;
  • take responsibility for forecasts of general government deficit and debt.

Eurostat's tools

Eurostat's GFS Directorate uses the following tools and procedures to assess the quality of the EDP and GFS statistics transmitted by EU Member States:

  • Bi-annually, with the spring and autumn EDP notifications, an extensive analysis of the notified tables is carried out over a period of 3 weeks. The main EDP tables are accompanied by a series of related annex tables that allow powerful cross-checking, in particular tracking the translation from the national 'working balances' to ESA surplus/deficit and checking the consistency of the deficits/surpluses with the reported changes in debt.
  • Quarterly, the analysis of EU Member States' quarterly transmissions of general government non-financial, financial accounts, balance sheets and debt, which are also used in a preventive way to anticipate issues arising in the bi-annual notifications.
  • Regular 'EDP dialogue visits' to EU Member States, following standardised procedures and agendas, giving rise to public reports. Dialogue visits to national statistical authorities cover statistical and upstream issues, the latter directed at examining inputs to the GFS reporting of national statistical authorities.
  • An internal annual country risk assessment, based on auditing practices adapted to EDP needs, which is used to address preventive action to Member States deemed to be at higher risk. As a standard, Member States are visited every 2 years. However, if necessary, they may be visited more frequently.
  • team of desk officers, each responsible for a maximum of 2 EU Member States, who follow daily, weekly and monthly agreed procedures to monitor public finance issues and exchange information with their counterparts in their respective countries. They coordinate with DG ECFIN and ECB country desks.
  • team of methodologists who participate in the visits.
  • A methodological team and a working group, the EDP Statistics Working Group (EDPS WG) devoted to methodological issues, composed of experts from National Statistical Institutes and National Central Banks.
  • A group of experts from NSIs and Central Banks, the Committee on Monetary, Financial and Balance of Payments Statistics (CMFB), acting as an advisory body, through consultations that follow rigorous rules of procedure.
  • The power to organise 'methodological' visits, where appropriate, express 'reservations' or 'amend' EDP data notified by national statistical authorities, and recommend to the Council financial sanctions in cases of deliberate misreporting or serious negligence in the reporting of EDP statistics (Regulation (EU) No 1173/2011).

The detailed description of the Eurostat’s processes and tools in relation to the EDP statistics is presented in the Eurostat inventory of EDP processes.

Further reading