Overview of pre-notified and notified eID schemes under eIDAS

Hi, is there a list of notified eIDs somewhere? 

thanks 

andrea

Thank you!

Short question: what about Italy, Croatia, Estonia and Luxembourg "undergoing the pre-notification process ending in July"?

https://twitter.com/ServidaAndrea/status/992497034904121344

Dear Andrea DE MARIA and Sebastian WOLPERS, information about the pre-notified eID schemes has been published. Best, Marie

Hi Marie. No problem with the sharing. Thank you.

Dear colleagues, I summarized main application issues regarding mutual recognition of electronic identification means in the Slovak Republic in my article (especially chapter 4). If you deal with the same problems I would be grateful to hear your opinions on how it works in your country. Link to the article (page 9 – 13): http://www.magnanimitas.cz/ADALTA/0702/papers/A_androsko.pdf  Best, Jozef.

Hi Marie EICHHOLTZER just a quick update from UK: two days ago, the 28th of August, we have uploaded all docs in order to pre-notify the UK digital identity scheme, Verify.

Regards! 

Hi Marina KIROVA & Marie EICHHOLTZER, it is nice to see that Italian eID has also been notified finally. However, I am a bit confused regarding the assurance levels that have been finally recognized. In this overview table, "low", "substantial" and "high" are presented, but when I follow the link on the OEJU Column /2018/C 318/02 then I see only substantial and low for Italy. Is this an editorial mistake, or how should one interpret this? Which assurance level will be finally recognized for SPID?

Dear Marie EICHHOLTZER thanks for the prompt reply. I would like to avoid confusion with one more comment: Italy has now now only pre-notified, but also received the notification of its eID scheme since 3 days, as I see. So the OJEU information will then contain all three assurance levels (including high)?

The eID_EU mentioned at 19 september on Twitter that Spain ande Luxemburg notified their eID's. Is this page to be updated soon?

This is a quite helpful ressource, have't seen it before. Would it possible to add links to the opinions of the CN on the peer reviewed schemes? Best, Jens

In connection with the pre-notification of the British eID scheme, acceptance into eIDAS depends on the decision of the Cooperation Network. Certain matters for their consideration are listed here, https://www.dmossesq.com/2018/10/rip-ida-international-id-slapstick.html

Dear Marie,

I noticed the change you made regarding the Italian eID.  First: Derived from TAX Code or VAT code for businesses (on which i would expect that this mean can be used for company-users) Now: Derived from SPID Code (so only civilians?) Why is this change made, the mean is allready notified? It seems a major change to me.

Kind regards,

Gertjan

Will the pre-notification supporting documents for The United Kingdom be published here? 

Hi,

Thanks for the useful information, out of the 10 notified eID schemes indicated as notified, 3 (EE, AT, DE) are currently integrated in EU login and additionally 1 NL (in peer review) in EU login ACC as well. Would you have a date for when the 7 others will be available in EU login ( PT, CZ, IT (2x), ES,HR, BE, UK, LU, IT) 

CEF EID is it possible to provide an update of this page? The last edit was on Jan 02, 2019.

How can I find out the reason for the fact, that Hungary is missing from this list of eID schemes?

Hi Andras Uzonyi, this list only shows pre-notified and notified eID schemes. I don't believe Hungary has yet pre-notified a scheme. Are there plans to do so?

Best,

George O'Neill

Dear Marie

The UK exited the EU on 31 January 2020.

Statutory Instrument (SI) No.89 2019 was laid before the UK Parliament on 23 January 2019 and came into force on "exit day".

The title of that SI is The Electronic Identification and Trust Services for Electronic Transactions (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019. It relates to eIDAS and states in the explanatory notes that:

Chapter II of the eIDAS Regulation provides for the mutual recognition and interoperability between EU Member States pertaining to the use of electronic identity schemes. It requires that public sector digital services using electronic identities above a described assurance level must accept electronic identities from ‘notified’ schemes in other EU Member States. Notification is a process whereby Member States choose to have their electronic identity scheme recognised and accepted by the other Member States.

These provisions are being revoked because Chapter II of the eIDAS Regulation establishes reciprocal arrangements between public bodies in the UK and EU Member States that will no longer be appropriate once the UK has withdrawn from the UK. The UK will no longer be an EU Member State following the UK’s withdrawal from the EU and will therefore no longer have access to the mutual recognition and interoperability framework for electronic identification provided by the eIDAS Regulation. Accordingly, the implementing legislation that gives effect to Chapter II of the eIDAS Regulation is also being revoked. These amendments are necessary in order to remove these deficient provisions from the UK statute book.

In view of that, is it correct to include the UK in the Overview of pre-notified and notified eID schemes under eIDAS above? If not,, to avoid confusion, should you perhaps delete the UK entry?

CEF EID The current page is now empty, where is the publicly available page of the Notified eID schemes under the eIDAS Regulation?

Hi. Austrian Page https://www.oesterreich.gv.at/en/themen/dokumente_und_recht/elektronische-identit%C3%A4t-(eiD)-anderer-eu-mitgliedstaaten-(SDG).html sais, it is part of eID. Why I am not able to select it? 

Dear all, I noticed that neither Iceland, Liechtenstein nor Norway are on this - would the EEA countries that are not EU members be elegible for inclusion in the program, or have none of these three tried to notify a system yet? Thanks very much for any info - this page is a great resource - thanks very much! 

Dear admin, 

Would it be possible to add columns with functions that schemes enable? For example can it be used only for authenticating users or can it be used for signing (QES level) and does it include time stamp by trust service provider? Building cross-border services requires service providers sometimes to request high assurance level eID authentication together with QES and time stamp. This limits the number of suitable eID schemes and caps the number of potential users.

Hi. Would it be possible to know when the French applications will be available ? Thank you very much.

Hi,

In January 2021 János Krizsán wrote, that "Hungary has not pre-notified any eID scheme yet, nevertheless, we expect to do so in 2021."

Is there any change concerning this expectation? Is there a new plan or deadline ?

Thanks!

Hello,

Any chance that Romania is in the works to be added to the list?

Kind regards,

Iulia

Dear Iulia,

Romania has not pre-notified any eID scheme, but it is planned. Please note that Romania's national electronic ID (smartcard) is currently under development. We will update this response when a more detailed timeline has been announced.

Please find here more details on the process to notify an eID scheme: How to notify an eID scheme? (europa.eu)

Best,

eID onboarding team

I can't find any information about Slovenia anywhere? Do you have any information about any Slovenian eID scheme?

Best Regards,

Marko

Hallo, how come that Sweden has notified 3 eID means (BankID, Freja eID and EFOS) under the scheme but in official journal only one (Freja eID) is published as notified? What are the reasons for this? Why BankID is eliminated?

Best regards,

Azuolas

It would be necessary to update in the header the date of last modification.  The list was actualised even in 2022, but according the header it was done lest time in 02, 2019.

Best regards 

karoly

Hello - is there any notified id scheme that can be provided to non-EU citizens / residents (e.g., a Chinese natural person living in China that never lived in an EU state)?

Thanks in advance

Francesco

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-Residency_of_Estonia

two eID schemes from poland have "notified" status. But .... it is impossible to add them to EuLogin account.