The person liable to pay the VAT due on a transaction to the tax authorities is usually the supplier, but it may also be the customer. In the case of the customer, it is not only taxable persons (businesses) who may have to pay the tax (as in a reverse-charge supply or on an intra-EU acquisition) but sometimes also a non-taxable legal entity.
The basic rule
VAT is payable by any taxable person making a taxable supply (‘the supplier’) of goods or services, unless it is payable by another person (Article 193 VAT Directive).
These can be divided into:
- transactions where the customer must pay the VAT:
see Transactions where the customer must pay the tax
- transactions where an EU country may choose to designate the customer as the person who pays:
see Transactions where the customer may be the person liable
- the importation of goods where the importer or other designated person must pay the tax:
see Obligation to pay: imports
- cases where goods are removed from customs warehouses and other suspensive arrangements and where the person causing the removal must pay:
see Obligation to pay: end of suspensive arrangements
- cases where a person (rightly or wrongly) enters an amount of VAT on an invoice:
see Obligation to pay: VAT on an invoice.
The transactions in which the customer must be the person liable to tax are set out in Articles 195-198 and 200 VAT Directive.
In what follows, ‘a non-established business’ means a business not established in the EU country where the tax is due. For these purposes, even if a business has a fixed establishment in a particular EU country, it is not regarded as established there if that fixed establishment does not intervene in a taxable supply of goods or services the business makes in that EU country (Article 192a VAT Directive).
The transactions in question are as follows:
- Supplies of natural gas through a natural gas system or connected network and supplies of electricity, heat or cooling energy through a heating or cooling network:
see Supplies of natural gas etc
- Those services for which the place of supply is the Member State of the customer:
see Services supplied where the customer is located
- The ultimate customer in a triangular transaction:
see Obligations: triangular transactions
- Specific transactions in investment gold:
see Transactions in investment gold
- A taxable intra-EU acquisition:
see Taxable intra-EU acquisitions
The obligation to pay VAT is the customer’s where the supply is one of:
- natural gas through a natural gas system or any network connected to such a system
- electricity or
- heat or cooling energy through a heating or cooling network
- a taxable dealer or
- in any other circumstance
by a taxable person not established in the EU country where the tax is due (Article 195 VAT Directive).
In the case of a supply to a taxable dealer, that is the Member State in which the dealer is established (Article 38 VAT Directive). In any other case, the tax is due in the Member State in which the customer effectively uses and consumes the goods. However, if the customer does not effectively consume part or all of the gas, electricity, heat or cooling energy, the rest is deemed to have been used and consumed in the Member State in which the customer is established (Article 39 VAT Directive).
Under Article 196 VAT Directive, the person liable for VAT is the customer where:
- that customer is a business acting as such or a non-taxable legal entity registered for VAT;
- the supply is one of services of which the place of supply is where the customer is established (this is the default rule for services supplied to taxable persons - see Article 44 VAT Directive); and
- the supplier is a business not established in the EU country of the customer.
What is the rule?
In a triangular transaction, the ultimate customer is the person liable to pay VAT, provided that the customer is a taxable person or a non-taxable legal person registered for VAT in the EU country where the final supply takes place.
What is a triangular transaction?
A triangular transaction is one in which a business established in EU country A supplies goods to a customer in EU country B, but the goods are shipped directly to the customer from a third EU country (C).
A business in Belgium receives an order for widgets from a customer in Italy. The widgets are made on behalf of the Belgian supplier by a manufacturer in Ireland, who ships them directly to the Italian customer.
Thus, there are two supplies and an intra-EU acquisition:
What are the precise conditions that must be satisfied?
The conditions for triangulation to apply and the customer to be liable to tax are that:
- the taxable transaction is a supply of goods carried out in accordance with the conditions laid down [for the simplification method for triangular transactions];
- the person to whom the goods are supplied is another business, or a non-taxable legal entity, registered for VAT in the EU country in which the supply is carried out; and
- the invoice issued by the supplier not established in the EU country of the person to whom the goods are supplied is drawn up in accordance with [the rules for valid VAT invoices].
Exception for tax representatives
Where the supplier has appointed a tax representative to comply with his VAT obligations on his behalf, EU countries may not apply the rule.
When the customer must be liable
As part of the special scheme for transactions in investment gold an EU country may tax specific transactions between taxable persons who are members of a regulated gold bullion market or between a taxable person who is such a member and another taxable person who is not (Article 352 VAT Directive).
Where this is in operation, the customer must be the person designated as liable for payment of VAT.
However, if the customer is a taxable person who is not a member of a regulated bullion market and needs to register for VAT in the EU country in which the supply takes place solely because of a taxed transaction, the vendor (the supplier) must take over the customer’s tax obligations in the way that the EU country provides.
When the customer may be liable
EU countries may opt to designate the customer as the person liable to pay the tax in transactions:
- involving gold material or semi-manufactured products of a purity of 32.5% or more or investment gold
- where the supplier is a taxable person producing, processing or supplying gold who has waived exemption under Articles 348-350 VAT Directive.
A person who makes a taxable intra-EU acquisition of goods is the person liable to pay the tax.
An intra-EU supply will normally be exempt, hence the obligation to pay the VAT falls on the customer.
For the exemption of intra-EU supplies, see Exemptions for intra-EU supplies
In addition to those instances where it is mandatory that the customer pays the VAT due on a transaction, there are also instances where EU countries may choose to designate the customer as the person liable for payment.
These instances are set out in Articles 194, 199, 199a and 199b VAT Directive and are, briefly:
- Taxable supplies where the supplier is not established in the EU country where the supply takes place.
- A range of designated supplies, such as construction work and the supply in certain circumstances of immovable property.
- Certain fraud-sensitive supplies such as emissions allowances (time-limited to 31 December 2018).
A very broad option is allowed to EU countries to designate the customer as the person liable to pay the VAT due on a supply instead of the supplier wherever the supplier is a taxable person who is not established in the EU country where the tax is due (Article 194 VAT Directive).
For these purposes, even if a taxable person has a fixed establishment in a particular EU country, he is not regarded as established there if that fixed establishment does not intervene in a taxable supply of goods or services the taxable person makes in that EU country (Article 192a VAT Directive).
EU countries may choose to designate the customer as the person liable to pay the VAT where the customer is a taxable person and the supply is any one of a number prescribed (Article 199 VAT Directive).
Most of these supplies are connected with immovable property. Remember that the place of supply of services connected with immovable property is where the property is located (see Where to tax: immovable property services).
The supplies in question are:
- the supply of construction work, including repair, cleaning, maintenance, alteration and demolition services in relation to immovable property, as well as the handing over of construction works treated by the EU country concerned as a supply of goods (under Article 14(3) VAT Directive);
- the supply of staff engaged in activities covered under the above bullet point;
- the supply of a building or part of a building and of the land on which it stands (other than the supply of that building or part prior to its first occupation), and of land that has not been built on (other than building land), where the supplier has opted for taxation of the supply (which would otherwise be exempt);
- the supply of used material, used material that cannot be reused in the same state, scrap, industrial and non-industrial waste, recyclable waste, part-processed waste and certain goods and services, such as scrap metal, listed (Annex VI VAT Directive);
- the supply of goods provided as security by one taxable person to another in execution of that security;
- the supply of goods following the cession of a reservation of ownership to an assignee and the exercising of this right by the assignee;
- the supply of immovable property sold by a judgment debtor in a compulsory sale procedure.
Where EU countries elect to make the customer liable, they are at liberty to choose which of these supplies will be covered by the option and to which categories of suppliers and customers it will refer.
For these purposes, EU countries may also regard non-taxable legal entities covered by public law (public bodies) as taxable persons where they receive the last three categories of supply mentioned.
For a limited period of at least two years, but ending no later than 31 December 2018, EU countries may designate the customer who is a taxable person as the person liable to pay the VAT due on fraud-sensitive goods or services such as a transfer of emissions allowances and related supplies.
The primary reason for allowing the option is to fight fraud.
The supplies concerned are:
- the transfer of allowances to emit greenhouse gases as defined in Article 3 Directive 2003/87/EC (establishing a scheme for greenhouse-gas emission allowance trading within the European Union), transferable in accordance with Article 12 of that Directive;
- the transfer of other units that may be used by operators for compliance with the same Directive;
- supplies of mobile telephones, being devices made or adapted for use in connection with a licensed network and operated on specified frequencies, whether or not they have any other use;
- supplies of integrated circuit devices such as microprocessors and central processing units in a state prior to integration into end user products;
- supplies of gas and electricity to a taxable dealer as defined in Article 38(2);
- supplies of gas and electricity certificates;
- supplies of telecommunication services as defined in Article 24(2);
- supplies of game consoles, tablet PCs and laptops;
- supplies of cereals and industrial crops including oil seeds and sugar beet, that are not normally used in the unaltered state for final consumption;
- supplies of raw and semi-finished metals, including precious metals (if not otherwise covered as used material under point (d) of Article 199(1), the special arrangements for second-hand goods etc. or the special scheme for investment gold).
Where EU countries exercise this option, they must provide information to the EU Commission concerning:
- a statement on the scope of the measure applying the option and a detailed description of accompanying measures, including any reporting obligations on taxable persons and any control measures;
- evaluation criteria to enable comparison between fraudulent activities in relation to the services concerned before and after the application of the option, fraudulent activities in relation to other services before and after the application of the option, and any increase in other types of fraudulent activities before and after the application of the option;
- the date of commencement and the period to be covered by the measure applying the option.
When goods are imported, the person liable to pay the VAT is the person designated or recognized as liable to pay by the EU country in which the importation takes place (Article 201 VAT Directive).
This is usually the customer or an import agent acting on the customer’s behalf. The customer may be a taxable person or a non-taxable person, such as a private individual.
Where the customer is a taxable person who imports the goods for the purposes of his taxed transactions, he may claim the import VAT as deductible input VAT.
When goods are imported, they may be placed in a customs warehouse or some other ‘suspensive arrangement’ – an arrangement for deferring import VAT and/or customs duties and possibly also excise duties on the goods until they are released into free circulation for final use or consumption.
When goods leave such an arrangement, the person causing them to be removed is the person liable to pay the VAT (Article 202 VAT Directive).
Whoever enters an amount of VAT as due on an invoice must pay that VAT, even if the entry was in error or even if the person is not entitled to charge VAT (Article 203 VAT Directive).