enEnglish
CROS

Track 5 - Tourism number of nights spent at hotels and similar accommodation

    2016-01 2016-02 2016-03 2016-04 2016-05 2016-06 2016-07 2016-08 2016-09 2016-10 2016-11 2016-12
AT RRMSE 8713294 10318480 9595174 4272536 5619330 6444485 9996416 11399594 7726801 5727389    
P4Approach4 5.711% 8815513 10015593 8610856 4659083 5280142 6792650 9392929 11112859 7596414 5485658 3765548  
P4Approach2 5.790% 8816717 10009194 8607728 4689742 5262003 6768178 9389784 11135292 7611645 5516607 3750901  
P4Approach5 6.767% 8858590 9977580 8496923 4797088 5207625 6800664 9362701 11100625 7546503 5436875 3642633  
P4Approach3 7.823% 8901064 9942767 8384554 4919763 5144177 6820914 9334045 11077174 7488976 5372618 3499386  
P4Approach1 7.823% 8901064 9942767 8384554 4919763 5144177 6820914 9334045 11077174 7488976 5372618 3554698  
P3Approach1 7.950% 8766880 9858319 8464827 4979702 5169386 6873951 9293395 10920786 7530501 5491870 3667208 7221245
P3Approach7 9.306% 8591542 10351235 8888068 5328281 5169386 6873951 9293395 10920786 7530501 5491870 3667208 7221245
P3Approach4 9.997% 8898383 10506504 9021389 5488129 5324468 7080170 9572197 11248410 7756416 5656626 3667208 7437882
P3Approach6 10.482% 7671020 9833673 8443665 5274998 5117692 6805211 9200461 10811578 7455196 5436951 3663541 7149033
P3Approach3 10.486% 8947992 10187324 8661520 5484296 5324108 7086080 9453898 10912401 7532459 5538629 3711610 7258886
P3Approach12 10.570% 8766880 10558260 9065829 5541412 5169386 6873951 9293395 10920786 7530501 5491870 3667208 7221245
P3Approach2 10.573% 9129103 9546109 8033307 5271320 5478829 7298209 9614402 10904016 7534417 5585388 3756012 7296528
P3Approach5 10.618% 8942218 10558260 9065829 5594695 5427855 7045800 9525730 11193806 7718764 5629167 3667208 7401776
P3Approach17 10.929% 8591542 10558260 9065829 5594695 5169386 6873951 9293395 10920786 7530501 5491870 3667208 7221245
P3Approach14 11.040% 8947992 10391070 8834750 5593982 5324108 7086080 9453898 10912401 7532459 5538629 3711610 7258886
P3Approach20 11.040% 8947992 10391070 8834750 5593982 5324108 7086080 9453898 10912401 7532459 5538629 3711610 7258886
P3Approach16 11.104% 7671020 10030346 8612538 5433248 5117692 6805211 9200461 10811578 7455196 5436951 3663541 7149033
P3Approach15 11.827% 8898383 10716634 9201817 5762535 5324468 7080170 9572197 11248410 7756416 5656626 3667208 7437882
P3Approach10 12.150% 7987965 10023414 8434972 5640312 5478829 7298209 9614402 10904016 7534417 5585388 3756012 7296528
P3Approach13 13.224% 9129103 10223882 8603671 5865924 5478829 7298209 9614402 10904016 7534417 5585388 3756012 7296528
P3Approach9 13.672% 9311685 10424351 8772371 5922328 5752770 7444173 9806690 11122096 7685105 5697096 3756012 7442459
P3Approach8 13.976% 9266040 10273999 8645846 5950529 5780165 7480664 9854762 11176616 7722777 5725023 3756012 7478941
P3Approach11 13.996% 8946521 10123648 8519322 5978731 5478829 7298209 9614402 10904016 7534417 5585388 3756012 7296528
P3Approach19 14.791% 9311685 10632838 8947818 6099998 5752770 7444173 9806690 11122096 7685105 5697096 3756012 7442459
P3Approach18 15.465% 9266040 10479479 8818763 6188550 5780165 7480664 9854762 11176616 7722777 5725023 3756012 7478941
BE RRMSE 919915 946962 1201271 1248536 1387739 1352778 1547084 1546627 1393437      
P4Approach5 10.008% 950030 1066805 1307658 1545363 1435080 1393652 1569115 1668149 1415031 1413748 1404480  
P4Approach20 10.008% 950030 1066805 1307658 1545363 1435080 1393652 1569115 1668149 1415031 1413748 1404480  
P4Approach15 10.008% 950030 1066805 1307658 1545363 1435080 1393652 1569115 1668149 1415031 1413748 1404480  
P4Approach10 10.008% 950030 1066805 1307658 1545363 1435080 1393652 1569115 1668149 1415031 1413748 1404480  
P4Approach9 10.303% 938434 1038937 1310662 1568896 1317495 1398186 1576816 1679224 1411494 1410143 1439179  
P4Approach4 10.303% 938434 1038937 1310662 1568896 1317495 1398186 1576816 1679224 1411494 1410143 1439179  
P4Approach19 10.303% 938434 1038937 1310662 1568896 1317495 1398186 1576816 1679224 1411494 1410143 1439179  
P4Approach14 10.303% 938434 1038937 1310662 1568896 1317495 1398186 1576816 1679224 1411494 1410143 1439179  
P4Approach2 10.518% 938434 1038937 1310662 1570833 1317495 1410425 1583910 1695297 1427793 1429856 1445724  
P4Approach7 10.518% 938434 1038937 1310662 1570833 1317495 1410425 1583910 1695297 1427793 1429856 1445724  
P4Approach17 10.518% 938434 1038937 1310662 1570833 1317495 1410425 1583910 1695297 1427793 1429856 1445724  
P4Approach12 10.518% 938434 1038937 1310662 1570833 1317495 1410425 1583910 1695297 1427793 1429856 1445724  
P4Approach8 10.571% 961627 1094674 1304653 1520862 1552664 1382999 1557867 1649038 1410419 1407498 1366509  
P4Approach3 10.571% 961627 1094674 1304653 1520862 1552664 1382999 1557867 1649038 1410419 1407498 1366509  
P4Approach1 10.571% 961627 1094674 1304653 1520862 1552664 1382999 1557867 1649038 1410419 1407498 1366509  
P4Approach6 10.571% 961627 1094674 1304653 1520862 1552664 1382999 1557867 1649038 1410419 1407498 1366509  
P4Approach18 10.571% 961627 1094674 1304653 1520862 1552664 1382999 1557867 1649038 1410419 1407498 1366509  
P4Approach16 10.571% 961627 1094674 1304653 1520862 1552664 1382999 1557867 1649038 1410419 1407498 1366509  
P4Approach13 10.571% 961627 1094674 1304653 1520862 1552664 1382999 1557867 1649038 1410419 1407498 1366509  
P4Approach11 10.571% 961627 1094674 1304653 1520862 1552664 1382999 1557867 1649038 1410419 1407498 1366509  
P3Approach1 11.187% 929095 1114787 1304456 1562159 1501010 1340326 1541266 1638829 1368263 1387691 1459108 1429090
P3Approach2 12.682% 994116 1167551 1327422 1568935 1463741 1332487 1560953 1639286 1374026 1393432 1446923 1425898
P3Approach6 13.558% 812958 1112000 1301195 1654795 1486000 1326923 1525853 1622441 1354580 1373814 1457649 1414799
P3Approach7 14.941% 910513 1170526 1369679 1671510 1501010 1340326 1541266 1638829 1368263 1387691 1459108 1429090
P3Approach16 15.118% 812958 1134240 1327219 1704439 1486000 1326923 1525853 1622441 1354580 1373814 1457649 1414799
P3Approach3 15.649% 961606 1198228 1381736 1675135 1482376 1336406 1551110 1639058 1371144 1390562 1453016 1427494
P3Approach10 16.373% 869852 1225929 1393793 1678760 1463741 1332487 1560953 1639286 1374026 1393432 1446923 1425898
P3Approach4 16.879% 943031 1188084 1390224 1721655 1546040 1380536 1587504 1687994 1409311 1429322 1459108 1471963
P3Approach12 16.972% 929095 1193937 1397073 1738370 1501010 1340326 1541266 1638829 1368263 1387691 1459108 1429090
P3Approach14 17.028% 961606 1222193 1409371 1708638 1482376 1336406 1551110 1639058 1371144 1390562 1453016 1427494
P3Approach20 17.028% 961606 1222193 1409371 1708638 1482376 1336406 1551110 1639058 1371144 1390562 1453016 1427494
P3Approach17 17.319% 910513 1193937 1397073 1755086 1501010 1340326 1541266 1638829 1368263 1387691 1459108 1429090
P3Approach5 17.847% 947677 1193937 1397073 1755086 1576060 1373834 1579798 1679800 1402470 1422383 1459108 1464817
P3Approach13 18.519% 994116 1250448 1421669 1745910 1463741 1332487 1560953 1639286 1374026 1393432 1446923 1425898
P3Approach11 18.724% 974234 1238188 1407731 1779486 1463741 1332487 1560953 1639286 1374026 1393432 1446923 1425898
P3Approach15 19.283% 943031 1211846 1418028 1807738 1546040 1380536 1587504 1687994 1409311 1429322 1459108 1471963
P3Approach8 19.688% 1009028 1256577 1428638 1771092 1544247 1365799 1599977 1680268 1408377 1428268 1446923 1461545
P3Approach9 20.049% 1013998 1274966 1449545 1762698 1536928 1359137 1592172 1672072 1401507 1421301 1446923 1454416
P3Approach18 21.787% 1009028 1281709 1457211 1841936 1544247 1365799 1599977 1680268 1408377 1428268 1446923 1461545
P3Approach19 21.817% 1013998 1300465 1478536 1815579 1536928 1359137 1592172 1672072 1401507 1421301 1446923 1454416
BG RRMSE 751293 829420 683275 752341 1283849 3395735 5246104 5342880 2895051 815500    
P4Approach5 8.824% 640664 699193 632960 770967 1325270 3156071 5049946 4858910 2763993 887634 775403  
P3Approach9 11.197% 694159 780830 694494 783020 1145204 2820880 4576438 4838247 2647393 981355 1008590 810276
P3Approach8 11.205% 690756 769568 684478 786748 1150657 2834708 4598872 4861963 2660370 986166 1008590 814248
P3Approach19 11.319% 694159 796447 708384 806511 1145204 2820880 4576438 4838247 2647393 981355 1008590 810276
P3Approach18 11.369% 690756 784959 698168 818218 1150657 2834708 4598872 4861963 2660370 986166 1008590 814248
P4Approach3 11.590% 615768 691801 616170 814059 1547055 3590167 5658474 4944261 2811444 813721 631733  
P4Approach1 11.797% 606045 691801 616170 814059 1547055 3590167 5658474 4944261 2811444 813721 631733  
P3Approach13 12.221% 680548 765814 681139 775562 1090670 2765569 4486704 4743379 2595483 962113 1008590 794388
P3Approach11 12.504% 666937 758306 674461 790477 1090670 2765569 4486704 4743379 2595483 962113 1008590 794388
P4Approach4 12.638% 671055 705544 653040 730210 1112578 2766403 4440250 4768528 2716542 961548 959472  
P3Approach14 12.868% 676356 760070 677957 762256 1090812 2764894 4488205 4745354 2640008 998126 1011214 783681
P3Approach20 12.868% 676356 760070 677957 762256 1090812 2764894 4488205 4745354 2640008 998126 1011214 783681
P3Approach3 13.018% 676356 745167 664664 747310 1090812 2764894 4488205 4745354 2640008 998126 1011214 783681
P3Approach2 13.105% 680548 715046 635984 696947 1090670 2765569 4486704 4743379 2595483 962113 1008590 794388
P3Approach5 13.132% 685606 754327 674776 786330 1145502 2833324 4601949 4866013 2751645 1059991 1013837 792298
P4Approach2 13.210% 669789 707628 646462 725539 1094391 2677548 4442585 4778589 2716542 961548 878672  
P3Approach4 13.306% 682245 750629 671468 771353 1123683 2847146 4624397 4889750 2765068 1065162 1013837 796163
P3Approach15 13.374% 682245 765642 684897 809921 1123683 2847146 4624397 4889750 2765068 1065162 1013837 796163
P3Approach10 13.647% 595480 750798 667783 745733 1090670 2765569 4486704 4743379 2595483 962113 1008590 794388
P3Approach12 13.720% 672163 754327 674776 778841 1090954 2764219 4489706 4747330 2684532 1034138 1013837 772974
P3Approach17 13.897% 658720 754327 674776 786330 1090954 2764219 4489706 4747330 2684532 1034138 1013837 772974
P3Approach7 13.982% 658720 739536 661545 748886 1090954 2764219 4489706 4747330 2684532 1034138 1013837 772974
P3Approach1 14.571% 672163 704320 630043 699893 1090954 2764219 4489706 4747330 2684532 1034138 1013837 772974
P3Approach16 15.568% 588143 716610 641037 763639 1080044 2736577 4444809 4699857 2657687 1023797 1012823 765244
P3Approach6 15.807% 588143 702559 628468 741397 1080044 2736577 4444809 4699857 2657687 1023797 1012823 765244
CY RRMSE 227187 299677 470931 877937 1726620 2030136 2294101 2334059 2015967      
P3Approach6 6.557% 234953 316692 440455 878350 1582147 1807872 2138461 2245444 1872213 1432822 562025 273939
P3Approach16 6.700% 234953 323026 449264 904700 1582147 1807872 2138461 2245444 1872213 1432822 562025 273939
P4Approach2 6.869% 248958 303702 436252 801778 1564483 1891596 2140203 2269495 1940195 1488473 544903  
P4Approach4 7.222% 255673 307633 435048 792625 1578896 1870499 2204238 2323131 1986895 1547361 591957  
P4Approach5 7.514% 227285 307705 462302 784115 1492695 1780551 2135998 2308496 2019886 1578576 659707  
P3Approach7 8.281% 263148 333360 463637 887222 1598128 1826133 2160062 2268125 1891124 1447295 562588 276706
P3Approach1 8.646% 268518 317486 441559 829179 1598128 1826133 2160062 2268125 1891124 1447295 562588 276706
P3Approach4 8.681% 272546 338360 470592 913839 1646072 1880917 2224864 2336169 1947858 1490714 562588 285007
P3Approach17 8.858% 263148 340027 472910 931583 1598128 1826133 2160062 2268125 1891124 1447295 562588 276706
P3Approach5 9.051% 273888 340027 472910 931583 1678034 1871786 2214064 2324828 1938402 1483477 562588 283624
P3Approach12 9.281% 268518 340027 472910 922711 1598128 1826133 2160062 2268125 1891124 1447295 562588 276706
P3Approach15 9.516% 272546 345127 480004 959531 1646072 1880917 2224864 2336169 1947858 1490714 562588 285007
P4Approach3 10.549% 202255 309743 488953 771030 1413700 1680055 2099776 2320679 2076227 1639236 750983  
P4Approach1 10.549% 202255 309743 488953 771030 1413700 1680055 2099776 2320679 2076227 1639236 750983  
P3Approach10 11.318% 262299 364079 525321 943081 1632625 1856493 2135877 2126437 1898088 1513221 599464 283633
P3Approach3 11.443% 284144 348720 494479 915152 1615376 1841313 2147970 2197281 1894606 1480258 581026 280170
P3Approach14 12.053% 284144 355694 504369 933455 1615376 1841313 2147970 2197281 1894606 1480258 581026 280170
P3Approach20 12.053% 284144 355694 504369 933455 1615376 1841313 2147970 2197281 1894606 1480258 581026 280170
P3Approach2 13.208% 299770 346742 500306 881384 1632625 1856493 2135877 2126437 1898088 1513221 599464 283633
P3Approach11 14.873% 293775 367720 530574 999666 1632625 1856493 2135877 2126437 1898088 1513221 599464 283633
P3Approach13 15.577% 299770 371361 535827 980804 1632625 1856493 2135877 2126437 1898088 1513221 599464 283633
P3Approach8 15.819% 304267 373181 538454 994950 1722419 1902905 2189274 2179598 1945540 1551052 599464 290724
P3Approach9 16.490% 305765 378642 546334 990235 1714256 1893623 2178595 2168966 1936050 1543485 599464 289306
P3Approach18 16.973% 304267 380645 549223 1034748 1722419 1902905 2189274 2179598 1945540 1551052 599464 290724
P3Approach19 17.527% 305765 386215 557261 1019942 1714256 1893623 2178595 2168966 1936050 1543485 599464 289306
CZ RRMSE 2077309 2397936 2788350 2635132 3224386 3192702 4259953 4328720 3454080 3133941    
P4Approach2 4.646% 2116497 2276306 2533612 2706290 3240161 3283447 3895672 4178165 3506080 3133120 2436085  
P4Approach7 4.646% 2116497 2276306 2533612 2706290 3240161 3283447 3895672 4178165 3506080 3133120 2436085  
P3Approach1 4.755% 2189296 2405794 2510819 2706341 3276692 3460562 4103636 4353773 3454297 3073074 2407104 2501572
P3Approach7 5.074% 2145510 2526084 2636360 2895785 3276692 3460562 4103636 4353773 3454297 3073074 2407104 2501572
P4Approach5 5.135% 2129989 2294528 2566215 2747557 3292904 3307505 3837711 4086341 3539227 3195468 2409485  
P4Approach10 5.135% 2129989 2294528 2566215 2747557 3292904 3307505 3837711 4086341 3539227 3195468 2409485  
P4Approach9 5.233% 2162830 2318661 2513807 2692805 3255493 3306221 3865889 4126554 3596378 3212881 2484194  
P4Approach4 5.233% 2162830 2318661 2513807 2692805 3255493 3306221 3865889 4126554 3596378 3212881 2484194  
P3Approach3 5.398% 2185286 2516404 2631170 2891621 3278442 3464177 4012024 4311727 3515674 3099998 2363630 2446750
P3Approach2 5.410% 2181277 2387356 2500932 2698558 3280191 3467792 3920412 4269681 3577051 3126921 2320156 2391928
P4Approach8 5.591% 2120315 2291573 2608721 2795566 3337982 3320176 3794641 4020322 3527224 3217936 2358830  
P4Approach3 5.591% 2120315 2291573 2608721 2795566 3337982 3320176 3794641 4020322 3527224 3217936 2358830  
P4Approach1 5.591% 2120315 2291573 2608721 2795566 3337982 3320176 3794641 4020322 3527224 3217936 2358830  
P4Approach6 5.591% 2120315 2291573 2608721 2795566 3337982 3320176 3794641 4020322 3527224 3217936 2358830  
P3Approach6 5.713% 1915634 2399780 2504542 2866827 3243925 3425956 4062600 4310235 3419754 3042343 2404697 2476556
P3Approach14 5.886% 2185286 2566732 2683793 2949453 3278442 3464177 4012024 4311727 3515674 3099998 2363630 2446750
P3Approach20 5.886% 2185286 2566732 2683793 2949453 3278442 3464177 4012024 4311727 3515674 3099998 2363630 2446750
P3Approach16 6.045% 1915634 2447776 2554633 2952832 3243925 3425956 4062600 4310235 3419754 3042343 2404697 2476556
P3Approach10 6.062% 1908617 2506724 2625979 2887457 3280191 3467792 3920412 4269681 3577051 3126921 2320156 2391928
P3Approach12 6.261% 2189296 2576606 2689087 3011616 3276692 3460562 4103636 4353773 3454297 3073074 2407104 2501572
P3Approach17 6.374% 2145510 2576606 2689087 3040574 3276692 3460562 4103636 4353773 3454297 3073074 2407104 2501572
P3Approach13 6.593% 2181277 2556858 2678499 3002955 3280191 3467792 3920412 4269681 3577051 3126921 2320156 2391928
P3Approach4 6.839% 2222135 2563975 2675905 2982659 3374993 3564379 4226745 4484386 3557926 3165266 2407104 2576619
P3Approach11 6.925% 2137651 2531791 2652239 3060704 3280191 3467792 3920412 4269681 3577051 3126921 2320156 2391928
P3Approach5 7.396% 2233082 2576606 2689087 3040574 3440527 3547076 4206227 4462617 3540654 3149901 2407104 2564111
P3Approach9 7.701% 2224903 2606993 2731018 3031830 3444201 3537148 3998820 4355075 3648592 3189459 2320156 2439767
P3Approach8 7.799% 2213996 2569392 2691628 3046267 3460602 3554487 4018422 4376423 3666477 3205094 2320156 2451726
P3Approach15 8.194% 2222135 2615254 2729423 3131792 3374993 3564379 4226745 4484386 3557926 3165266 2407104 2576619
P3Approach19 8.644% 2224903 2659133 2785638 3122785 3444201 3537148 3998820 4355075 3648592 3189459 2320156 2439767
P3Approach18 8.942% 2213996 2620780 2745461 3168118 3460602 3554487 4018422 4376423 3666477 3205094 2320156 2451726
DE RRMSE 15801624 17622346 20715048 21725051 25898364 25579466 28594771 29066078 28393443      
P3Approach2 1.941% 15915260 17268441 19999101 21616764 26042714 26176359 28408169 30003005 28172123 26656307 20130163 19516148
P3Approach1 2.015% 15871517 17196070 19961505 21636464 26209753 26146969 28226720 29911131 28169214 26671465 20173112 19505927
P4Approach2 2.033% 16183807 17416871 19992843 21696918 26120279 26392354 28440942 29797571 28226661 26652219 20128490  
P4Approach7 2.033% 16183807 17416871 19992843 21696918 26120279 26392354 28440942 29797571 28226661 26652219 20128490  
P4Approach9 2.092% 16131812 17339790 19997199 21749486 26215059 26395284 28409650 29892088 28246717 26723144 20128490  
P4Approach4 2.092% 16131812 17339790 19997199 21749486 26215059 26395284 28409650 29892088 28246717 26723144 20128490  
P4Approach5 2.444% 15763576 17088610 19859884 21707341 26298158 26526542 28592632 30038846 28265921 26742898 20026516  
P4Approach10 2.444% 15763576 17088610 19859884 21707341 26298158 26526542 28592632 30038846 28265921 26742898 20026516  
P3Approach3 2.758% 15893388 18093868 20979318 23140476 26126234 26161664 28317444 29957068 28170668 26663886 20151638 19511038
P3Approach7 2.791% 15554087 18055874 20959580 23151016 26209753 26146969 28226720 29911131 28169214 26671465 20173112 19505927
P4Approach8 3.176% 15369343 16798890 19724746 21691479 26428647 26659266 28759968 30232862 28295153 26798114 19924543  
P4Approach3 3.176% 15369343 16798890 19724746 21691479 26428647 26659266 28759968 30232862 28295153 26798114 19924543  
P4Approach1 3.176% 15369343 16798890 19724746 21691479 26428647 26659266 28759968 30232862 28295153 26798114 19924543  
P4Approach6 3.176% 15369343 16798890 19724746 21691479 26428647 26659266 28759968 30232862 28295153 26798114 19924543  
P3Approach14 3.731% 15893388 18455745 21398904 23603286 26126234 26161664 28317444 29957068 28170668 26663886 20151638 19511038
P3Approach20 3.731% 15893388 18455745 21398904 23603286 26126234 26161664 28317444 29957068 28170668 26663886 20151638 19511038
P3Approach12 4.283% 15871517 18416991 21378772 24077057 26209753 26146969 28226720 29911131 28169214 26671465 20173112 19505927
P3Approach13 4.330% 15915260 18494500 21419037 24055134 26042714 26176359 28408169 30003005 28172123 26656307 20130163 19516148
P3Approach17 4.614% 15554087 18416991 21378772 24308567 26209753 26146969 28226720 29911131 28169214 26671465 20173112 19505927
P3Approach11 4.774% 15596955 18313182 21209047 24517733 26042714 26176359 28408169 30003005 28172123 26656307 20130163 19516148
P3Approach10 4.832% 13925852 18131863 20999056 23129937 26042714 26176359 28408169 30003005 28172123 26656307 20130163 19516148
P3Approach4 4.850% 16109590 18326712 21273974 23845546 26996046 26931378 29073522 30808465 29014290 27471609 20173112 20091105
P3Approach6 4.858% 13887577 17153080 19911601 22919506 25947655 25885499 27944453 29612020 27887522 26404750 20152939 19310868
P3Approach16 5.158% 13887577 17496142 20309833 23607091 25947655 25885499 27944453 29612020 27887522 26404750 20152939 19310868
P3Approach5 5.521% 16188947 18416991 21378772 24308567 27520241 26800643 28932388 30658909 28873444 27338252 20173112 19993575
P3Approach8 5.801% 16153989 18585160 21524032 24402084 27475063 26830768 29118373 30753080 28876426 27322715 20130163 20004052
P3Approach9 5.837% 16233565 18857138 21839018 24286434 27344850 26699886 28976332 30603065 28735565 27189433 20130163 19906471
P3Approach15 6.543% 16109590 18693246 21699453 25037823 26996046 26931378 29073522 30808465 29014290 27471609 20173112 20091105
P3Approach19 7.140% 16233565 19234281 22275798 25015027 27344850 26699886 28976332 30603065 28735565 27189433 20130163 19906471
P3Approach18 7.317% 16153989 18956863 21954513 25378167 27475063 26830768 29118373 30753080 28876426 27322715 20130163 20004052
DK RRMSE 779106 861242 1020317 1148235 1375491 1498862 1959668 1744933 1372512 1249827    
P4Approach8 2.206% 823272 852706 1004503 1133957 1389551 1484100 1963298 1779451 1401484 1263296 1115626  
P4Approach3 2.206% 823272 852706 1004503 1133957 1389551 1484100 1963298 1779451 1401484 1263296 1115626  
P4Approach1 2.206% 823272 852706 1004503 1133957 1389551 1484100 1963298 1779451 1401484 1263296 1115626  
P4Approach6 2.206% 823272 852706 1004503 1133957 1389551 1484100 1963298 1779451 1401484 1263296 1115626  
P3Approach6 5.509% 794977 925677 1108473 1282682 1393652 1477407 1914931 1726940 1411714 1295477 1139084 942306
P3Approach16 6.872% 794977 944191 1130642 1321162 1393652 1477407 1914931 1726940 1411714 1295477 1139084 942306
P3Approach1 6.999% 908545 927997 1111251 1210877 1407729 1492330 1934274 1744384 1425974 1308563 1140224 951824
P4Approach5 7.834% 899070 907736 971243 1104468 1280985 1375761 1851840 1682598 1505184 1345617 1150278  
P4Approach10 7.834% 899070 907736 971243 1104468 1280985 1375761 1851840 1682598 1505184 1345617 1150278  
P3Approach3 8.308% 857240 962446 1086284 1225028 1343725 1405092 1724832 1610308 1517598 1279458 1132097 937932
P3Approach7 8.900% 890374 974397 1166814 1295638 1407729 1492330 1934274 1744384 1425974 1308563 1140224 951824
P3Approach14 9.016% 857240 981695 1108010 1249529 1343725 1405092 1724832 1610308 1517598 1279458 1132097 937932
P3Approach20 9.016% 857240 981695 1108010 1249529 1343725 1405092 1724832 1610308 1517598 1279458 1132097 937932
P3Approach17 10.509% 890374 993885 1190150 1360420 1407729 1492330 1934274 1744384 1425974 1308563 1140224 951824
P3Approach12 10.658% 908545 993885 1190150 1347464 1407729 1492330 1934274 1744384 1425974 1308563 1140224 951824
P3Approach4 11.121% 922173 989013 1184316 1334507 1449961 1537100 1992302 1796716 1468753 1347820 1140224 980379
P3Approach2 11.639% 805934 905234 957861 1078896 1279721 1317853 1515389 1476233 1609221 1250352 1123970 924040
P3Approach8 11.645% 818023 974258 1030898 1217912 1350106 1350799 1553274 1513139 1649452 1281611 1123970 947141
P3Approach5 11.738% 926716 993885 1190150 1360420 1478115 1529638 1982631 1787994 1461623 1341277 1140224 975620
P3Approach11 11.915% 789815 960001 1015812 1223684 1279721 1317853 1515389 1476233 1609221 1250352 1123970 924040
P3Approach9 11.916% 822053 988516 1045984 1212140 1343707 1344210 1545697 1505758 1641405 1275359 1123970 942521
P3Approach13 11.974% 805934 969506 1025869 1200596 1279721 1317853 1515389 1476233 1609221 1250352 1123970 924040
P3Approach10 12.011% 705192 950496 1005754 1154419 1279721 1317853 1515389 1476233 1609221 1250352 1123970 924040
P3Approach18 12.241% 818023 993743 1051516 1266628 1350106 1350799 1553274 1513139 1649452 1281611 1123970 947141
P3Approach19 12.462% 822053 1008286 1066904 1248504 1343707 1344210 1545697 1505758 1641405 1275359 1123970 942521
P3Approach15 12.699% 922173 1008793 1208002 1401232 1449961 1537100 1992302 1796716 1468753 1347820 1140224 980379
P4Approach2 14.233% 970387 962291 928496 1079136 1174178 1266388 1707446 1540577 1620012 1365396 1155604  
P4Approach7 14.233% 970387 962291 928496 1079136 1174178 1266388 1707446 1540577 1620012 1365396 1155604  
P4Approach9 14.589% 979348 963242 947468 1070822 1170659 1268454 1773317 1630914 1597757 1490481 1214257  
P4Approach4 14.589% 979348 963242 947468 1070822 1170659 1268454 1773317 1630914 1597757 1490481 1214257  
EE RRMSE 283601 278540 339381 368569 437124 505042 685553 588905 403582 428594    
P3Approach4 2.624% 279860 291913 329393 378459 438030 490637 679790 568018 413160 433050 355844 391427
P4Approach5 2.996% 287505 279199 317403 346041 442589 503865 687875 574391 405105 431797 366995  
P4Approach10 2.996% 287505 279199 317403 346041 442589 503865 687875 574391 405105 431797 366995  
P4Approach8 3.015% 284485 277846 315609 348513 446969 507471 697377 582213 399018 423912 358032  
P4Approach3 3.015% 284485 277846 315609 348513 446969 507471 697377 582213 399018 423912 358032  
P4Approach1 3.015% 284485 277846 315609 348513 446969 507471 697377 582213 399018 423912 358032  
P4Approach6 3.015% 284485 277846 315609 348513 446969 507471 697377 582213 399018 423912 358032  
P3Approach3 3.035% 281990 288340 326830 369182 428272 479794 667224 558838 398910 422416 358496 377741
P3Approach5 3.071% 281238 293351 331016 385808 446536 488256 676490 565261 411154 430948 355844 389527
P3Approach13 3.190% 288256 294863 335717 385766 431271 483241 674459 566203 396694 424396 361148 375456
P3Approach14 3.242% 281990 294107 333367 376566 428272 479794 667224 558838 398910 422416 358496 377741
P3Approach20 3.242% 281990 294107 333367 376566 428272 479794 667224 558838 398910 422416 358496 377741
P3Approach11 3.376% 282491 291972 332425 393185 431271 483241 674459 566203 396694 424396 361148 375456
P4Approach9 3.384% 290524 280552 319198 343570 438209 500258 678372 566569 411193 439681 375958  
P4Approach2 3.384% 290524 280552 319198 343570 438209 500258 678372 566569 411193 439681 375958  
P4Approach7 3.384% 290524 280552 319198 343570 438209 500258 678372 566569 411193 439681 375958  
P4Approach4 3.384% 290524 280552 319198 343570 438209 500258 678372 566569 411193 439681 375958  
P3Approach8 3.395% 292580 296308 337362 391330 454991 495322 691320 580358 406611 435006 361148 384842
P3Approach9 3.647% 294021 300644 342299 389475 452835 492906 687948 577527 404628 432884 361148 382965
P3Approach2 3.735% 288256 275315 313461 346663 431271 483241 674459 566203 396694 424396 361148 375456
P3Approach15 3.736% 279860 297751 335981 397382 438030 490637 679790 568018 413160 433050 355844 391427
P3Approach7 3.874% 270210 287599 324525 367436 425272 476347 659990 551474 401126 420437 355844 380026
P3Approach12 3.918% 275724 293351 331016 382133 425272 476347 659990 551474 401126 420437 355844 380026
P3Approach17 4.201% 270210 293351 331016 385808 425272 476347 659990 551474 401126 420437 355844 380026
P3Approach10 4.336% 252224 289081 329134 370929 431271 483241 674459 566203 396694 424396 361148 375456
P3Approach18 4.680% 292580 302234 344109 406983 454991 495322 691320 580358 406611 435006 361148 384842
P3Approach19 4.748% 294021 306657 349145 401159 452835 492906 687948 577527 404628 432884 361148 382965
P3Approach1 4.846% 275724 273904 309071 343398 425272 476347 659990 551474 401126 420437 355844 380026
P3Approach16 6.505% 241258 278683 314465 374675 421019 471584 653390 545959 397115 416233 355488 376226
P3Approach6 6.750% 241258 273219 308299 363762 421019 471584 653390 545959 397115 416233 355488 376226
ES RRMSE 14437332 16315715 21877829 23387155 30813666 34952632 42777182 46492618 36647655 29896141    
P3Approach1 5.656% 15081415 15623987 19787828 24304633 29794037 33898855 45685851 51098947 37820397 30149139 18138742 17202245
P3Approach7 5.762% 14779787 16405186 20777219 26005957 29794037 33898855 45685851 51098947 37820397 30149139 18138742 17202245
P3Approach6 6.638% 13196238 15584927 19738358 25745897 29496097 33559866 45228992 50587958 37442193 29847648 18120603 17030223
P3Approach12 6.756% 15081415 16733290 21192763 27046195 29794037 33898855 45685851 51098947 37820397 30149139 18138742 17202245
P3Approach16 6.875% 13196238 15896626 20133125 26518274 29496097 33559866 45228992 50587958 37442193 29847648 18120603 17030223
P3Approach17 6.915% 14779787 16733290 21192763 27306255 29794037 33898855 45685851 51098947 37820397 30149139 18138742 17202245
P3Approach3 7.456% 14708769 14504352 20729728 26072400 30127938 34077088 46990454 52228118 37672312 30260154 18345704 17120156
P3Approach14 7.480% 14708769 14794439 21144323 26593848 30127938 34077088 46990454 52228118 37672312 30260154 18345704 17120156
P3Approach20 7.480% 14708769 14794439 21144323 26593848 30127938 34077088 46990454 52228118 37672312 30260154 18345704 17120156
P3Approach4 7.707% 15307636 16651264 21088877 26786136 30687858 34915821 47056427 52631915 38955009 31053613 18138742 17718312
P3Approach5 7.983% 15383043 16733290 21192763 27306255 31283739 34746326 46827997 52376421 38765907 30902867 18138742 17632301
P3Approach15 8.920% 15307636 16984289 21510655 28125443 30687858 34915821 47056427 52631915 38955009 31053613 18138742 17718312
P3Approach13 10.605% 14336123 12855589 21095883 27184398 30461838 34255322 48295058 53357289 37524226 30371168 18552666 17038066
P3Approach2 11.028% 14336123 12003351 19697370 24428826 30461838 34255322 48295058 53357289 37524226 30371168 18552666 17038066
P4Approach5 11.129% 14418946 15443806 20593280 24382422 30342280 34793559 42165661 30813666 37573063 28997190 17200163  
P4Approach1 11.144% 14068113 15762096 21072459 24980083 30435494 35309340 43028200 30813666 37065217 28481392 16776500  
P3Approach11 11.180% 14049401 12729554 20889060 27707175 30461838 34255322 48295058 53357289 37524226 30371168 18552666 17038066
P3Approach10 11.206% 12544108 12603519 20682238 26138844 30461838 34255322 48295058 53357289 37524226 30371168 18552666 17038066
P4Approach3 11.208% 14068113 15762096 20547761 24342127 30435494 35309340 43028200 30813666 38367353 28481392 16776500  
P4Approach2 11.213% 14713068 15095665 20636264 23961519 30317368 34297725 41386821 30813666 37383598 29512987 17623827  
P3Approach9 11.226% 14622845 13107660 21509528 27445786 31984930 34940428 49260959 54424435 38274711 30978591 18552666 17378827
P4Approach4 11.409% 14826492 15155365 20116635 24245961 30180765 34257828 41219424 30813666 37476081 29512987 17623827  
P3Approach19 11.539% 14622845 13369813 21939719 28269160 31984930 34940428 49260959 54424435 38274711 30978591 18552666 17378827
P3Approach8 11.760% 14551165 12918607 21199294 27576480 32137239 35111705 49502434 54691221 38462332 31130447 18552666 17464018
P3Approach18 12.258% 14551165 13176979 21623280 28679539 32137239 35111705 49502434 54691221 38462332 31130447 18552666 17464018
EU RRMSE 96451204 106274263 124449437 132814434 164497883 188769915 238472144 254766275 193262871      
P4Approach3 1.299% 97024948 104909792 122156596 134987558 162202655 192489593 237616796 257466946 192889164 151198847 102399169  
P4Approach1 1.299% 97024948 104909792 122156596 134987558 162202655 192489593 237616796 257466946 192889164 151198847 103263671  
P4Approach5 1.817% 97290829 104820744 119247371 132779536 161810463 192711304 236495329 256470993 190945713 155182942 104722941  
P4Approach2 2.243% 97502941 104744329 118302058 129796273 162228405 192669850 235103753 255816982 189341439 159572523 107574490  
P3Approach1 2.336% 99398597 107449760 117272064 134154596 164474428 191014260 234752084 255341112 192110840 158061247 105366388 106256907
P4Approach4 3.136% 97610479 104719062 114374234 131346754 160608137 193196181 235643970 255133096 188663086 158761550 105654432  
P3Approach7 3.490% 97410625 112822248 123135667 143545418 164474428 191014260 234752084 255341112 192110840 158061247 105366388 106256907
P3Approach3 4.176% 97956142 111431819 122818056 143359826 164447357 190717425 234288738 237351044 185693293 149574618 104790966 102235507
P3Approach6 4.630% 86973772 107181136 116978884 142109964 162829684 189104117 232404563 252787701 190189732 156480635 105261022 105194338
P3Approach14 4.937% 97956142 113660455 125274417 146227023 164447357 190717425 234288738 237351044 185693293 149574618 104790966 102235507
P3Approach20 4.937% 97956142 113660455 125274417 146227023 164447357 190717425 234288738 237351044 185693293 149574618 104790966 102235507
P3Approach16 5.128% 86973772 109324759 119318462 146373263 162829684 189104117 232404563 252787701 190189732 156480635 105261022 105194338
P3Approach12 5.131% 99398597 115078693 125598380 149287235 164474428 191014260 234752084 255341112 192110840 158061247 105366388 106256907
P3Approach4 5.318% 100889576 114514582 124982702 147851781 169408661 196744688 241794647 263001345 197874165 162803084 105366388 109444614
P3Approach17 5.339% 97410625 115078693 125598380 150722689 164474428 191014260 234752084 255341112 192110840 158061247 105366388 106256907
P3Approach2 5.693% 96513686 104801324 116667090 133807694 164420286 190420590 233825392 219360975 179275746 141087988 104215544 98214107
P3Approach5 6.037% 101386569 115078693 125598380 150722689 172698149 195789616 240620886 261724640 196913611 162012778 105366388 108913330
P3Approach13 6.900% 96513686 112242218 124950453 148901202 164420286 190420590 233825392 219360975 179275746 141087988 104215544 98214107
P3Approach8 6.936% 97961391 112792425 125562955 151048816 173463402 195181105 239671027 224844999 183757640 144615188 104215544 100669460
P3Approach9 7.095% 98443960 114443046 127400462 150332945 172641300 194229002 238501900 223748194 182861261 143909748 104215544 100178389
P3Approach15 7.113% 100889576 116804874 127482356 155244370 169408661 196744688 241794647 263001345 197874165 162803084 105366388 109444614
P3Approach11 7.293% 94583412 111141804 123725448 151764687 164420286 190420590 233825392 219360975 179275746 141087988 104215544 98214107
P3Approach10 7.309% 84449475 110041390 122500444 143174233 164420286 190420590 233825392 219360975 179275746 141087988 104215544 98214107
P3Approach19 8.204% 98443960 116731907 129948471 154842933 172641300 194229002 238501900 223748194 182861261 143909748 104215544 100178389
P3Approach18 8.279% 97961391 115048274 128074214 157090769 173463402 195181105 239671027 224844999 183757640 144615188 104215544 100669460
FI RRMSE 1123721 1281340 1409151 1214006 1158343 1488264 2055982 1668715 1365393 1266873    
P3Approach7 2.160% 1123599 1284715 1434250 1246036 1177318 1543494 2075245 1649621 1309577 1280229 1175882 1244802
P4Approach2 2.299% 1152587 1279362 1388318 1179185 1183892 1547817 2057106 1654051 1316453 1281461 1195924  
P4Approach7 2.299% 1152587 1279362 1388318 1179185 1183892 1547817 2057106 1654051 1316453 1281461 1195924  
P4Approach9 2.318% 1145835 1279362 1381186 1171705 1176056 1540737 2050926 1647115 1309351 1275062 1195924  
P4Approach4 2.318% 1145835 1279362 1381186 1171705 1176056 1540737 2050926 1647115 1309351 1275062 1195924  
P4Approach5 2.369% 1151022 1268425 1384083 1174883 1180151 1542509 2044866 1647173 1310086 1275514 1197920  
P4Approach10 2.369% 1151022 1268425 1384083 1174883 1180151 1542509 2044866 1647173 1310086 1275514 1197920  
P4Approach1 2.471% 1152834 1257488 1383415 1174321 1180328 1540740 2035715 1643763 1308606 1273873 1199917  
P4Approach6 2.471% 1152834 1257488 1383415 1174321 1180328 1540740 2035715 1643763 1308606 1273873 1199917  
P4Approach8 2.501% 1152834 1257488 1383415 1174321 1180328 1540740 2035715 1643763 1305932 1271661 1199917  
P4Approach3 2.501% 1152834 1257488 1383415 1174321 1180328 1540740 2035715 1643763 1305932 1271661 1199917  
P3Approach3 2.705% 1168242 1326744 1429576 1248089 1175120 1541044 2066730 1651146 1307855 1280192 1179118 1232194
P3Approach1 2.949% 1146530 1223538 1365952 1164520 1177318 1543494 2075245 1649621 1309577 1280229 1175882 1244802
P3Approach2 3.154% 1189953 1303593 1357050 1168357 1172922 1538594 2058215 1652670 1306133 1280155 1182355 1219587
P3Approach12 3.252% 1146530 1310409 1462935 1295877 1177318 1543494 2075245 1649621 1309577 1280229 1175882 1244802
P3Approach17 3.414% 1123599 1310409 1462935 1308338 1177318 1543494 2075245 1649621 1309577 1280229 1175882 1244802
P3Approach14 3.434% 1168242 1353279 1458168 1273051 1175120 1541044 2066730 1651146 1307855 1280192 1179118 1232194
P3Approach20 3.434% 1168242 1353279 1458168 1273051 1175120 1541044 2066730 1651146 1307855 1280192 1179118 1232194
P3Approach10 3.801% 1041209 1368773 1424902 1250142 1172922 1538594 2058215 1652670 1306133 1280155 1182355 1219587
P3Approach4 4.064% 1163728 1303986 1455764 1283417 1212638 1589799 2137502 1699110 1348864 1318636 1175882 1282146
P3Approach16 4.293% 1003214 1244889 1389789 1270583 1165545 1528059 2054493 1633125 1296481 1267427 1174706 1232354
P3Approach6 4.344% 1003214 1220479 1362538 1233576 1165545 1528059 2054493 1633125 1296481 1267427 1174706 1232354
P3Approach11 4.459% 1166154 1382461 1439151 1325151 1172922 1538594 2058215 1652670 1306133 1280155 1182355 1219587
P3Approach13 4.573% 1189953 1396148 1453400 1300148 1172922 1538594 2058215 1652670 1306133 1280155 1182355 1219587
P3Approach5 4.593% 1169461 1310409 1462935 1308338 1236184 1582081 2127126 1690862 1342316 1312235 1175882 1275922
P3Approach15 5.318% 1163728 1330066 1484879 1347588 1212638 1589799 2137502 1699110 1348864 1318636 1175882 1282146
P3Approach8 5.848% 1207802 1402992 1460525 1318900 1237433 1577059 2109670 1693987 1338786 1312159 1182355 1250077
P3Approach9 6.087% 1213752 1423524 1481898 1312649 1231568 1569366 2099379 1685723 1332256 1305758 1182355 1243979
P3Approach18 7.083% 1207802 1431052 1489736 1371656 1237433 1577059 2109670 1693987 1338786 1312159 1182355 1250077
P3Approach19 7.170% 1213752 1451994 1511536 1352028 1231568 1569366 2099379 1685723 1332256 1305758 1182355 1243979
FR RRMSE 11621722 12913977 15723232 15876038 18640992 19630105 22771744 23158591 19231365 17436956    
P4Approach9 4.294% 12634479 13444604 15136340 16926933 19058194 19884076 22621596 24259010 19531176 17663954 12172343  
P4Approach4 4.294% 12634479 13444604 15136340 16926933 19058194 19884076 22621596 24259010 19531176 17663954 12172343  
P4Approach5 4.451% 12710836 13610334 15282526 16930145 18876987 19697321 22429546 24199341 19654986 17358137 12175244  
P4Approach10 4.451% 12710836 13610334 15282526 16930145 18876987 19697321 22429546 24199341 19654986 17358137 12175244  
P3Approach1 4.460% 12015247 12809066 14821495 16933124 19147359 20084022 22908173 24632908 19674829 18678145 12387911 13095964
P4Approach8 4.670% 12746025 13698627 15425113 16923336 18656885 19494671 22140159 24079958 19765327 16921575 12257477  
P4Approach3 4.670% 12746025 13698627 15425113 16923336 18656885 19494671 22140159 24079958 19765327 16921575 12257477  
P4Approach1 4.670% 12746025 13698627 15425113 16923336 18656885 19494671 22140159 24079958 19765327 16921575 12257987  
P4Approach6 4.670% 12746025 13698627 15425113 16923336 18656885 19494671 22140159 24079958 19765327 16921575 12257987  
P4Approach2 4.730% 12716814 13599481 15143540 16946975 19135985 19915868 22816268 24378437 19558114 17925446 12013167  
P4Approach7 4.730% 12716814 13599481 15143540 16946975 19135985 19915868 22816268 24378437 19558114 17925446 12013167  
P3Approach7 5.737% 11774942 13449519 15562570 18118443 19147359 20084022 22908173 24632908 19674829 18678145 12387911 13095964
P3Approach6 6.061% 10513341 12777043 14784442 17937259 18955885 19883182 22679091 24386579 19478081 18491364 12375523 12965004
P3Approach16 6.690% 10513341 13032584 15080131 18475377 18955885 19883182 22679091 24386579 19478081 18491364 12375523 12965004
P3Approach12 7.142% 12015247 13718509 15873821 18843181 19147359 20084022 22908173 24632908 19674829 18678145 12387911 13095964
P3Approach17 7.378% 11774942 13718509 15873821 19024365 19147359 20084022 22908173 24632908 19674829 18678145 12387911 13095964
P3Approach3 7.477% 12497111 13980896 15724726 18336017 19393957 20271570 23252394 24830903 19932452 19154634 12068848 12851545
P3Approach2 7.701% 12978975 13821212 15130365 17339805 19640555 20459117 23596614 25028898 20190076 19631124 11749784 12607126
P3Approach4 8.172% 12195476 13651262 15796009 18661996 19721780 20686543 23595418 25371895 20265074 19238489 12387911 13488843
P3Approach14 8.249% 12497111 14260514 16039221 18702737 19393957 20271570 23252394 24830903 19932452 19154634 12068848 12851545
P3Approach20 8.249% 12497111 14260514 16039221 18702737 19393957 20271570 23252394 24830903 19932452 19154634 12068848 12851545
P3Approach10 8.672% 11356603 14512273 15886883 18553591 19640555 20459117 23596614 25028898 20190076 19631124 11749784 12607126
P3Approach5 8.711% 12255552 13718509 15873821 19024365 20104727 20586123 23480877 25248731 20166700 19145099 12387911 13423363
P3Approach15 9.711% 12195476 13924287 16111929 19595096 19721780 20686543 23595418 25371895 20265074 19238489 12387911 13488843
P3Approach13 10.638% 12978975 14802518 16204621 19295735 19640555 20459117 23596614 25028898 20190076 19631124 11749784 12607126
P3Approach11 10.742% 12719396 14657396 16045752 19666806 19640555 20459117 23596614 25028898 20190076 19631124 11749784 12607126
P3Approach9 12.570% 13238554 15092764 16522358 19481271 20622583 20868299 24068546 25529476 20593878 20023746 11749784 12859269
P3Approach8 12.590% 13173660 14875080 16284055 19574039 20720786 20970595 24186529 25654620 20694828 20121902 11749784 12922304
P3Approach19 13.678% 13238554 15394619 16852805 20065709 20622583 20868299 24068546 25529476 20593878 20023746 11749784 12859269
P3Approach18 13.905% 13173660 15172582 16609736 20357001 20720786 20970595 24186529 25654620 20694828 20121902 11749784 12922304
HR RRMSE 257791 300000 617059 1140896 2155849 3158170 4789175 5036397 3488541 1514109    
P4Approach2 6.118% 276258 295019 524493 1164880 2115618 3067368 4476766 4788659 3378079 1491112 478947  
P3Approach1 7.371% 290376 294780 525280 1225991 2075402 3139230 4431421 4847664 3344319 1490645 474957 443926
P3Approach7 7.475% 284568 309519 551544 1311810 2075402 3139230 4431421 4847664 3344319 1490645 474957 443926
P4Approach5 7.575% 252376 272445 502515 1206497 2227221 3291453 4710347 5067119 3365277 1393853 401754  
P3Approach6 7.580% 254079 294043 523967 1298692 2054648 3107838 4387107 4799187 3310876 1475739 474482 439487
P3Approach10 7.635% 273290 329613 572102 1330041 2104317 3158632 4453317 4871289 3349953 1418315 398129 379396
P3Approach16 7.927% 254079 299924 534446 1337653 2054648 3107838 4387107 4799187 3310876 1475739 474482 439487
P3Approach4 8.283% 294732 314162 559817 1351164 2137664 3233407 4564364 4993094 3444649 1535364 474957 457244
P4Approach4 8.413% 242706 261026 492264 1151681 2142072 3061783 4432822 4869910 3346456 1491112 394882  
P3Approach17 8.641% 284568 315709 562575 1377400 2075402 3139230 4431421 4847664 3344319 1490645 474957 443926
P3Approach12 8.673% 290376 315709 562575 1364282 2075402 3139230 4431421 4847664 3344319 1490645 474957 443926
P3Approach3 8.737% 301354 319566 561823 1320926 2089860 3148931 4442369 4859476 3347136 1454480 436543 411661
P3Approach5 8.910% 296184 315709 562575 1377400 2179172 3217711 4542207 4968856 3427927 1527911 474957 455024
P3Approach2 8.987% 312332 313917 544859 1243029 2104317 3158632 4453317 4871289 3349953 1418315 398129 379396
P3Approach14 9.192% 301354 325957 573059 1347345 2089860 3148931 4442369 4859476 3347136 1454480 436543 411661
P3Approach20 9.192% 301354 325957 573059 1347345 2089860 3148931 4442369 4859476 3347136 1454480 436543 411661
P3Approach15 9.660% 294732 320445 571013 1418722 2137664 3233407 4564364 4993094 3444649 1535364 474957 457244
P4Approach3 10.384% 245270 266867 496652 1254713 2325596 3518331 4965900 5304953 3368286 1296595 366593  
P4Approach1 10.384% 245270 266867 496652 1254713 2325596 3518331 4965900 5304953 3368286 1296595 366593  
P3Approach11 10.904% 306085 332909 577823 1409843 2104317 3158632 4453317 4871289 3349953 1418315 398129 379396
P3Approach13 10.934% 312332 336205 583544 1383243 2104317 3158632 4453317 4871289 3349953 1418315 398129 379396
P3Approach8 11.387% 317017 337853 586405 1403193 2220054 3237598 4564650 4993071 3433702 1453773 398129 388881
P3Approach9 11.563% 318579 342798 594986 1396543 2209533 3221805 4542383 4968715 3416952 1446681 398129 386984
P3Approach19 12.552% 318579 349654 606886 1438439 2209533 3221805 4542383 4968715 3416952 1446681 398129 386984
P3Approach18 12.624% 317017 344610 598133 1459321 2220054 3237598 4564650 4993071 3433702 1453773 398129 388881
HU RRMSE 1179737 1256719 1586460 1608262 1898689 2010825 2866157 3048487 2043412 1929751    
P4Approach9 4.631% 1190418 1191106 1442616 1691899 1815242 2007883 2679180 2953507 2020119 1969329 1598045  
P4Approach4 4.631% 1190418 1191106 1442616 1691899 1815242 2007883 2679180 2953507 2020119 1969329 1598045  
P4Approach2 4.716% 1175877 1180118 1451163 1677705 1781914 2006676 2683341 2953507 2020119 1969329 1598045  
P4Approach7 4.716% 1175877 1180118 1451163 1677705 1781914 2006676 2683341 2953507 2020119 1969329 1598045  
P4Approach5 4.879% 1185727 1195214 1459617 1686816 1825986 1988310 2624276 2876643 2003909 1965205 1605293  
P4Approach10 4.879% 1185727 1195214 1459617 1686816 1825986 1988310 2624276 2876643 2003909 1965205 1605293  
P3Approach1 5.167% 1214002 1224563 1452399 1714289 1714289 2051069 2735737 2988009 1975947 1895102 1512421 1510147
P4Approach1 5.316% 1195375 1210706 1477349 1692800 1858812 1969340 2567292 2799779 1993648 1961271 1608569  
P4Approach6 5.316% 1195375 1210706 1477349 1692800 1858812 1969340 2567292 2799779 1993648 1961271 1608569  
P4Approach8 5.465% 1181240 1198927 1467338 1684859 1847977 1969340 2567292 2799779 1981751 1960892 1616515  
P4Approach3 5.465% 1181240 1198927 1467338 1684859 1847977 1969340 2567292 2799779 1981751 1960892 1616515  
P3Approach2 5.581% 1190975 1186139 1434190 1694864 1694864 2020776 2726740 2964454 1977042 1944388 1542301 1551889
P3Approach3 5.907% 1202488 1265618 1515460 1823896 1704576 2035922 2731238 2976232 1976494 1919745 1527361 1531018
P3Approach7 5.964% 1189722 1285791 1525019 1834289 1714289 2051069 2735737 2988009 1975947 1895102 1512421 1510147
P3Approach14 6.390% 1202488 1290930 1545769 1860374 1704576 2035922 2731238 2976232 1976494 1919745 1527361 1531018
P3Approach20 6.390% 1202488 1290930 1545769 1860374 1704576 2035922 2731238 2976232 1976494 1919745 1527361 1531018
P3Approach9 6.503% 1214794 1295264 1566136 1904179 1779607 2061192 2781275 3023743 2016583 1983276 1542301 1582927
P3Approach4 6.525% 1232212 1305078 1547894 1889318 1765718 2112601 2817809 3077649 2035225 1951955 1512421 1555451
P3Approach8 6.605% 1208840 1276582 1543547 1913247 1788082 2071295 2794908 3038565 2026468 1992998 1542301 1590686
P3Approach13 6.844% 1190975 1270355 1536018 1886044 1694864 2020776 2726740 2964454 1977042 1944388 1542301 1551889
P3Approach10 6.953% 1042103 1245446 1505900 1813504 1694864 2020776 2726740 2964454 1977042 1944388 1542301 1551889
P3Approach5 7.012% 1238282 1311507 1555519 1926003 1800003 2102346 2804130 3062709 2025346 1942480 1512421 1547901
P3Approach12 7.176% 1214002 1311507 1555519 1907661 1714289 2051069 2735737 2988009 1975947 1895102 1512421 1510147
P3Approach6 7.265% 1062252 1221501 1448768 1815946 1697146 2030558 2708380 2958129 1956188 1876151 1510909 1495046
P3Approach17 7.423% 1189722 1311507 1555519 1926003 1714289 2051069 2735737 2988009 1975947 1895102 1512421 1510147
P3Approach11 7.466% 1167156 1257900 1520959 1922314 1694864 2020776 2726740 2964454 1977042 1944388 1542301 1551889
P3Approach19 7.629% 1214794 1321169 1597459 1961304 1779607 2061192 2781275 3023743 2016583 1983276 1542301 1582927
P3Approach16 7.689% 1062252 1245931 1477743 1870424 1697146 2030558 2708380 2958129 1956188 1876151 1510909 1495046
P3Approach18 8.020% 1208840 1302114 1574418 1989777 1788082 2071295 2794908 3038565 2026468 1992998 1542301 1590686
P3Approach15 8.248% 1232212 1331180 1578852 1983784 1765718 2112601 2817809 3077649 2035225 1951955 1512421 1555451
IT RRMSE 12913275 13618342 16993390 15498758 19757396 28725815 41800571 46979912 29192031      
P4Approach2 6.073% 12277537 13606997 15155797 17143500 21305631 29467604 40911731 46277096 28660569 18678698 10496884  
P4Approach4 6.161% 12327374 13585054 15132887 17181891 21321427 29755721 40952006 46310411 28833518 18734845 10499036  
P4Approach5 6.231% 12397405 13441037 15270958 17368087 21208808 29991436 41233000 46601351 28384668 18123991 10240079  
P3Approach1 6.267% 12538738 13288442 15062188 17338850 21011508 29656882 40767263 46233742 28283518 18151236 10409834 11907737
P4Approach3 6.495% 12492354 13286049 15397574 17573478 21104088 30371210 41534131 46908949 28022293 17541211 9982198  
P4Approach1 6.495% 12492354 13286049 15397574 17573478 21104088 30371210 41534131 46908949 28022293 17541211 9982198  
P3Approach2 6.982% 12586249 13794985 14663941 17317754 21634973 29738523 41373496 46835950 28887935 18191698 10301221 11512616
P3Approach7 7.709% 12287963 13952864 15815297 18552570 21011508 29656882 40767263 46233742 28283518 18151236 10409834 11907737
P3Approach3 7.898% 12562494 14218799 15606218 18541284 21323240 29697702 41070380 46534846 28585726 18171467 10355528 11710176
P3Approach14 8.545% 12562494 14503175 15918342 18912110 21323240 29697702 41070380 46534846 28585726 18171467 10355528 11710176
P3Approach20 8.545% 12562494 14503175 15918342 18912110 21323240 29697702 41070380 46534846 28585726 18171467 10355528 11710176
P3Approach12 8.965% 12538738 14231921 16131603 19294673 21011508 29656882 40767263 46233742 28283518 18151236 10409834 11907737
P3Approach4 8.973% 12726819 14162157 16052526 19109147 21641853 30546588 41990281 47620754 29132024 18695773 10409834 12264969
P3Approach6 9.297% 10971396 13255221 15024532 18367044 20801393 29360313 40359590 45771405 28000683 17969724 10399424 11788660
P3Approach17 9.419% 12287963 14231921 16131603 19480198 21011508 29656882 40767263 46233742 28283518 18151236 10409834 11907737
P3Approach10 9.619% 11012968 14484734 15397138 18529997 21634973 29738523 41373496 46835950 28887935 18191698 10301221 11512616
P3Approach13 9.623% 12586249 14774429 15705081 19271197 21634973 29738523 41373496 46835950 28887935 18191698 10301221 11512616
P3Approach16 9.875% 10971396 13520325 15325023 18918055 20801393 29360313 40359590 45771405 28000683 17969724 10399424 11788660
P3Approach5 9.877% 12789513 14231921 16131603 19480198 22062083 30398304 41786445 47389586 28990606 18605017 10409834 12205430
P3Approach11 10.364% 12334524 14629581 15551109 19641797 21634973 29738523 41373496 46835950 28887935 18191698 10301221 11512616
P3Approach15 10.819% 12726819 14445400 16373577 20064604 21641853 30546588 41990281 47620754 29132024 18695773 10409834 12264969
P3Approach9 10.846% 12837974 15064123 16013024 19456497 22716722 30333293 42200966 47772669 29465694 18555532 10301221 11742868
P3Approach8 11.074% 12775043 14846852 15782066 19549147 22824897 30481986 42407833 48006849 29610133 18646490 10301221 11800431
P3Approach19 12.013% 12837974 15365405 16333284 20040192 22716722 30333293 42200966 47772669 29465694 18555532 10301221 11742868
P3Approach18 12.534% 12775043 15143789 16097707 20331113 22824897 30481986 42407833 48006849 29610133 18646490 10301221 11800431
LT RRMSE 227899 201061 256137 265689 362568 396933 454372 469785 354404      
P3Approach1 3.180% 225534 200674 236318 263138 350720 383184 456558 461937 347882 312871 272357 271098
P3Approach7 3.442% 221023 210708 248134 281558 350720 383184 456558 461937 347882 312871 272357 271098
P4Approach5 3.574% 213636 201518 242659 271508 357126 408768 471923 475452 340332 298993 259390  
P4Approach10 3.574% 213636 201518 242659 271508 357126 408768 471923 475452 340332 298993 259390  
P4Approach2 3.696% 217476 196706 234832 262005 351025 387761 455319 461527 344609 310754 268546  
P4Approach7 3.696% 217476 196706 234832 262005 351025 387761 455319 461527 344609 310754 268546  
P4Approach9 3.799% 212985 199201 236916 264148 350415 388459 454501 460150 343427 309928 269049  
P4Approach4 3.799% 212985 199201 236916 264148 350415 388459 454501 460150 343427 309928 269049  
P3Approach4 3.984% 228917 213869 251856 290005 361242 394680 470255 475795 358318 322257 272357 279231
P3Approach12 4.514% 225534 214922 253097 292820 350720 383184 456558 461937 347882 312871 272357 271098
P3Approach5 4.599% 230045 214922 253097 295636 368256 392764 467972 473485 356579 320693 272357 277875
P3Approach17 4.878% 221023 214922 253097 295636 350720 383184 456558 461937 347882 312871 272357 271098
P4Approach1 5.314% 212043 203460 249445 279940 363531 429426 488935 490067 336645 287645 249982  
P4Approach6 5.314% 212043 203460 249445 279940 363531 429426 488935 490067 336645 287645 249982  
P4Approach8 5.381% 212043 206706 249445 279940 363531 429426 488935 490067 336645 287645 249982  
P4Approach3 5.381% 212043 206706 249445 279940 363531 429426 488935 490067 336645 287645 249982  
P3Approach15 5.788% 228917 218146 256893 304505 361242 394680 470255 475795 358318 322257 272357 279231
P3Approach6 5.967% 197342 200173 235727 278742 347213 379352 451992 457318 344403 309742 272085 268387
P3Approach16 6.124% 197342 204176 240442 287104 347213 379352 451992 457318 344403 309742 272085 268387
P3Approach3 8.533% 208081 222434 256916 289887 324896 363766 417605 417578 339870 316708 267100 268312
P3Approach14 9.171% 208081 226883 262054 295685 324896 363766 417605 417578 339870 316708 267100 268312
P3Approach20 9.171% 208081 226883 262054 295685 324896 363766 417605 417578 339870 316708 267100 268312
P3Approach2 13.478% 190628 223009 253047 278707 299071 344347 378652 373219 331859 320545 261842 265526
P3Approach8 14.326% 193487 240013 272341 314618 315520 352956 388118 382549 340155 328559 261842 272164
P3Approach9 14.754% 194441 243525 276327 313127 314025 351234 386225 380683 338496 326956 261842 270837
P3Approach13 15.482% 190628 238842 271013 310145 299071 344347 378652 373219 331859 320545 261842 265526
P3Approach18 15.541% 193487 244813 277788 327203 315520 352956 388118 382549 340155 328559 261842 272164
P3Approach11 15.781% 186815 236501 268356 316109 299071 344347 378652 373219 331859 320545 261842 265526
P3Approach19 15.793% 194441 248396 281854 322521 314025 351234 386225 380683 338496 326956 261842 270837
P3Approach10 16.250% 166800 234159 265699 298216 299071 344347 378652 373219 331859 320545 261842 265526
LV RRMSE 200403 185350 226913 254305 320485 368126 455551 452130 314523 281973    
P3Approach2 2.949% 208775 195544 217986 255294 324424 360525 455946 440062 313832 291192 239641 233332
P3Approach1 3.192% 207855 198472 217080 254416 324203 358522 452162 439300 310456 284408 230144 232915
P4Approach8 3.277% 198308 187409 213861 243891 305392 356886 466481 445516 306027 273746 236239  
P4Approach3 3.277% 198308 187409 213861 243891 305392 356886 466481 445516 306027 273746 236239  
P4Approach1 3.435% 198725 189027 213077 242843 305258 357570 466868 448002 305690 272980 236239  
P4Approach6 3.435% 198725 189027 213077 242843 305258 357570 466868 448002 305690 272980 236239  
P4Approach5 3.998% 203877 188222 209155 241713 303043 352280 454092 434335 307563 282058 240387  
P4Approach10 3.998% 203877 188222 209155 241713 303043 352280 454092 434335 307563 282058 240387  
P3Approach3 4.716% 208315 206858 228410 272695 324314 359524 454054 439681 312144 287800 234892 233124
P3Approach6 4.734% 181873 197976 216537 269503 320961 354937 447640 434907 307351 281564 229914 230586
P3Approach7 4.757% 203698 208396 227934 272225 324203 358522 452162 439300 310456 284408 230144 232915
P3Approach10 5.232% 182678 205321 228885 273165 324424 360525 455946 440062 313832 291192 239641 233332
P4Approach9 5.246% 209238 188226 204841 240059 300762 348615 443115 422572 307899 289314 243550  
P4Approach4 5.246% 209238 188226 204841 240059 300762 348615 443115 422572 307899 289314 243550  
P3Approach16 5.405% 181873 201936 220868 277588 320961 354937 447640 434907 307351 281564 229914 230586
P4Approach2 5.429% 209238 188226 204841 240059 300762 346048 439905 421250 310636 292193 245519  
P4Approach7 5.429% 209238 188226 204841 240059 300762 346048 439905 421250 310636 292193 245519  
P3Approach14 5.670% 208315 210995 232978 278149 324314 359524 454054 439681 312144 287800 234892 233124
P3Approach20 5.670% 208315 210995 232978 278149 324314 359524 454054 439681 312144 287800 234892 233124
P3Approach13 5.961% 208775 209427 233463 284092 324424 360525 455946 440062 313832 291192 239641 233332
P3Approach11 6.041% 204600 207374 231174 289555 324424 360525 455946 440062 313832 291192 239641 233332
P3Approach4 6.139% 210973 211522 231353 280392 333929 369278 465727 452479 319770 292940 230144 239902
P3Approach12 6.188% 207855 212564 232493 283114 324203 358522 452162 439300 310456 284408 230144 232915
P3Approach17 6.303% 203698 212564 232493 285836 324203 358522 452162 439300 310456 284408 230144 232915
P3Approach5 6.809% 212012 212564 232493 285836 340413 367485 463466 450282 318217 291518 230144 238738
P3Approach8 7.056% 211907 210454 234607 288189 342267 369538 467345 451064 321678 298472 239641 239165
P3Approach9 7.308% 212950 213534 238040 286823 340645 367736 465065 448863 320109 297016 239641 237999
P3Approach15 7.760% 210973 215752 235980 294412 333929 369278 465727 452479 319770 292940 230144 239902
P3Approach18 8.510% 211907 214663 239299 299717 342267 369538 467345 451064 321678 298472 239641 239165
P3Approach19 8.558% 212950 217805 242801 295428 340645 367736 465065 448863 320109 297016 239641 237999
MT RRMSE 396704 471496 619144 714551 800319 848232 994285 619144 867610      
P4Approach9 25.528% 403754 455615 556209 698423 793377 892485 1045546 1086054 874862 785291 500306  
P4Approach4 25.528% 403754 455615 556209 698423 793377 892485 1045546 1086054 874862 785291 500306  
P4Approach2 26.292% 409085 464798 566029 709294 800302 902780 1059019 1100613 886428 791582 504204  
P4Approach7 26.292% 409085 464798 566029 709294 800302 902780 1059019 1100613 886428 791582 504204  
P3Approach6 27.526% 368102 479739 588792 787835 825939 897950 1074390 1118432 908709 798361 504906 398298
P3Approach16 27.677% 368102 489334 600568 811470 825939 897950 1074390 1118432 908709 798361 504906 398298
P3Approach1 28.014% 420688 480941 590268 743732 834282 907020 1085242 1129729 917888 806425 505411 402321
P3Approach2 28.071% 423474 481529 591292 744713 834383 907188 1085743 1130291 920501 814569 521053 400421
P3Approach7 28.243% 412274 504988 619781 795793 834282 907020 1085242 1129729 917888 806425 505411 402321
P3Approach3 28.318% 422081 505296 620319 796318 834332 907104 1085492 1130010 919194 810497 513232 401371
P3Approach10 28.348% 370540 505605 620857 796843 834383 907188 1085743 1130291 920501 814569 521053 400421
P3Approach14 28.506% 422081 515402 632725 812244 834332 907104 1085492 1130010 919194 810497 513232 401371
P3Approach20 28.506% 422081 515402 632725 812244 834332 907104 1085492 1130010 919194 810497 513232 401371
P3Approach12 28.599% 420688 515088 632177 827625 834282 907020 1085242 1129729 917888 806425 505411 402321
P3Approach17 28.628% 412274 515088 632177 835583 834282 907020 1085242 1129729 917888 806425 505411 402321
P3Approach13 28.670% 423474 515717 633274 828717 834383 907188 1085743 1130291 920501 814569 521053 400421
P3Approach11 28.727% 415005 510661 627066 844654 834383 907188 1085743 1130291 920501 814569 521053 400421
P4Approach5 29.392% 421445 463595 572251 704585 798176 908393 1101752 1155058 900787 770508 499255  
P4Approach10 29.392% 421445 463595 572251 704585 798176 908393 1101752 1155058 900787 770508 499255  
P3Approach9 30.411% 431943 525829 645691 836685 876102 925332 1107458 1152897 938911 830860 521053 408429
P3Approach5 30.571% 429102 515088 632177 835583 875996 929695 1112373 1157972 940835 826586 505411 412379
P3Approach4 30.693% 426998 512563 629078 819667 859310 934231 1117799 1163621 945425 830618 505411 414391
P3Approach8 30.711% 429826 518245 636378 840669 880274 929868 1112887 1158548 943514 834933 521053 410432
P3Approach19 30.794% 431943 536346 658605 861786 876102 925332 1107458 1152897 938911 830860 521053 408429
P3Approach15 31.151% 426998 522814 641660 860650 859310 934231 1117799 1163621 945425 830618 505411 414391
P3Approach18 31.164% 429826 528610 649106 874296 880274 929868 1112887 1158548 943514 834933 521053 410432
P4Approach8 33.016% 436471 466984 583383 705311 799513 919154 1151222 1216781 920930 752580 520756  
P4Approach3 33.016% 436471 466984 583383 705311 799513 919154 1151222 1216781 920930 752580 520756  
P4Approach1 33.016% 436471 466984 583383 705311 799513 919154 1151222 1216781 920930 752580 471755  
P4Approach6 33.016% 436471 466984 583383 705311 799513 919154 1151222 1216781 920930 752580 471755  
NL RRMSE 2704492 2857549 3486976 3838125 4183170 3906872 4479007 4740631 4011172 4003692    
P4Approach5 4.124% 2634221 2727684 3178718 3940799 4144880 4043271 4269548 4569696 3943583 3900470 3237423  
P4Approach10 4.124% 2634221 2727684 3178718 3940799 4144880 4043271 4269548 4569696 3943583 3900470 3237423  
P4Approach9 4.306% 2572110 2673265 3187266 3934606 4185491 4102179 4365076 4704568 3981774 3897131 3281518  
P4Approach4 4.306% 2572110 2673265 3187266 3934606 4185491 4102179 4365076 4704568 3981774 3897131 3281518  
P4Approach8 4.480% 2700342 2785704 3172785 3945547 4104511 3973914 4177761 4439982 3906566 3900733 3172465  
P4Approach3 4.480% 2700342 2785704 3172785 3945547 4104511 3973914 4177761 4439982 3906566 3900733 3172465  
P4Approach1 4.480% 2700342 2785704 3172785 3945547 4104511 3973914 4177761 4439982 3906566 3900733 3210424  
P4Approach6 4.480% 2700342 2785704 3172785 3945547 4104511 3973914 4177761 4439982 3906566 3900733 3210424  
P4Approach2 4.482% 2564090 2666063 3182036 3937495 4185006 4123077 4357594 4694254 3979425 3903284 3285285  
P4Approach7 4.482% 2564090 2666063 3182036 3937495 4185006 4123077 4357594 4694254 3979425 3903284 3285285  
P3Approach2 4.761% 2560404 2680005 3149877 3947770 4193442 4119881 4473026 4827946 3946730 3814583 3212908 3048719
P3Approach3 4.765% 2537525 2817916 3260392 4222291 4204307 4111998 4452745 4812396 3961991 3861120 3240762 3073032
P3Approach14 5.036% 2537525 2874274 3325600 4306737 4204307 4111998 4452745 4812396 3961991 3861120 3240762 3073032
P3Approach20 5.036% 2537525 2874274 3325600 4306737 4204307 4111998 4452745 4812396 3961991 3861120 3240762 3073032
P3Approach7 5.256% 2464353 2821826 3213413 4220468 4215172 4104115 4432464 4796847 3977252 3907656 3268616 3097345
P3Approach1 5.264% 2514646 2687453 3060393 3944363 4215172 4104115 4432464 4796847 3977252 3907656 3268616 3097345
P3Approach13 5.535% 2560404 2870285 3373518 4393079 4193442 4119881 4473026 4827946 3946730 3814583 3212908 3048719
P3Approach12 5.719% 2514646 2878263 3277681 4389287 4215172 4104115 4432464 4796847 3977252 3907656 3268616 3097345
P3Approach4 5.977% 2552366 2864153 3261614 4347082 4341627 4227238 4565438 4940752 4096570 4024886 3268616 3190265
P3Approach9 6.107% 2611612 2926565 3439666 4435320 4403114 4202279 4562487 4924505 4025665 3890875 3212908 3109693
P3Approach17 6.240% 2464353 2878263 3277681 4431491 4215172 4104115 4432464 4796847 3977252 3907656 3268616 3097345
P3Approach11 6.370% 2509196 2842145 3340445 4477561 4193442 4119881 4473026 4827946 3946730 3814583 3212908 3048719
P3Approach8 6.427% 2598810 2884355 3390055 4456440 4424081 4222878 4584852 4948645 4045398 3909948 3212908 3124937
P3Approach5 6.429% 2564939 2878263 3277681 4431491 4425931 4206718 4543276 4916768 4076683 4005347 3268616 3174779
P3Approach10 6.947% 2240354 2814005 3307371 4224114 4193442 4119881 4473026 4827946 3946730 3814583 3212908 3048719
P3Approach19 7.110% 2611612 2985096 3508459 4568380 4403114 4202279 4562487 4924505 4025665 3890875 3212908 3109693
P3Approach15 7.237% 2552366 2921436 3326846 4564436 4341627 4227238 4565438 4940752 4096570 4024886 3268616 3190265
P3Approach18 7.649% 2598810 2942042 3457856 4634698 4424081 4222878 4584852 4948645 4045398 3909948 3212908 3124937
P3Approach6 8.089% 2200315 2680735 3052742 4178263 4173020 4063074 4388139 4748879 3937479 3868579 3265347 3066372
P3Approach16 8.141% 2200315 2734350 3113797 4303611 4173020 4063074 4388139 4748879 3937479 3868579 3265347 3066372
PL RRMSE 2604705 2888304 2847398 3169453 3716536 4170414 5021976 5194227 4277860 3762751    
P3Approach1 5.342% 2625821 2798166 2908634 3075566 3724886 3913251 4570408 4750581 4277689 4076868 3388118 3021682
P3Approach2 5.499% 2608106 2780448 2905029 3072785 3726202 3905795 4521532 4722345 4264141 4036148 3372733 3080694
P4Approach9 5.709% 2532915 2733135 2894005 3106596 3700457 3935809 4562554 4717623 4331653 4102532 3390883  
P4Approach4 5.709% 2532915 2733135 2894005 3106596 3700457 3935809 4562554 4717623 4331653 4102532 3390883  
P4Approach14 5.709% 2532915 2733135 2894005 3106596 3700457 3935809 4562554 4717623 4331653 4102532 3390883  
P3Approach7 5.774% 2573305 2938074 3054066 3290856 3724886 3913251 4570408 4750581 4277689 4076868 3388118 3021682
P3Approach3 5.796% 2616964 2928772 3052173 3289368 3725544 3909523 4545970 4736463 4270915 4056508 3380426 3051188
P4Approach2 5.853% 2532915 2733135 2899953 3106287 3710368 3942711 4564007 4724848 4376133 4136742 3407866  
P4Approach7 5.853% 2532915 2733135 2899953 3106287 3710368 3942711 4564007 4724848 4376133 4136742 3407866  
P4Approach12 5.853% 2532915 2733135 2899953 3106287 3710368 3942711 4564007 4724848 4376133 4136742 3407866  
P3Approach4 6.171% 2665208 2982145 3099877 3389582 3836633 4030649 4707520 4893098 4406020 4199174 3388118 3112332
P4Approach5 6.253% 2534806 2710445 2921017 3154692 3786090 3977738 4528046 4657903 4443195 4131020 3346733  
P4Approach15 6.253% 2534806 2710445 2921017 3154692 3786090 3977738 4528046 4657903 4443195 4131020 3346733  
P4Approach10 6.253% 2534806 2710445 2921017 3154692 3786090 3977738 4528046 4657903 4443195 4131020 3346733  
P3Approach14 6.334% 2616964 2987347 3113216 3355155 3725544 3909523 4545970 4736463 4270915 4056508 3380426 3051188
P3Approach20 6.334% 2616964 2987347 3113216 3355155 3725544 3909523 4545970 4736463 4270915 4056508 3380426 3051188
P3Approach12 6.546% 2625821 2996835 3115147 3422490 3724886 3913251 4570408 4750581 4277689 4076868 3388118 3021682
P3Approach13 6.579% 2608106 2977859 3111286 3419395 3726202 3905795 4521532 4722345 4264141 4036148 3372733 3080694
P3Approach5 6.683% 2678337 2996835 3115147 3455399 3911130 4011082 4684668 4869346 4384631 4178790 3388118 3097224
P3Approach17 6.685% 2573305 2996835 3115147 3455399 3724886 3913251 4570408 4750581 4277689 4076868 3388118 3021682
P3Approach11 6.703% 2555944 2948665 3080783 3485153 3726202 3905795 4521532 4722345 4264141 4036148 3372733 3080694
P3Approach6 6.738% 2297593 2791170 2901363 3257947 3687637 3874118 4524704 4703075 4234912 4036099 3384730 2991465
P3Approach8 6.781% 2647228 2992457 3126537 3468713 3931143 4003440 4634570 4840404 4370745 4137052 3372733 3157711
P4Approach8 6.881% 2551740 2696642 2961252 3202942 3896462 4027239 4513622 4594571 4532497 4142403 3294091  
P4Approach3 6.881% 2551740 2696642 2961252 3202942 3896462 4027239 4513622 4594571 4532497 4142403 3294091  
P4Approach13 6.881% 2551740 2696642 2961252 3202942 3896462 4027239 4513622 4594571 4532497 4142403 3294091  
P3Approach16 6.953% 2297593 2846993 2959390 3355685 3687637 3874118 4524704 4703075 4234912 4036099 3384730 2991465
P4Approach1 6.991% 2521653 2678870 2928858 3202942 3837071 4005193 4472003 4594571 4532497 4142403 3294091  
P4Approach6 6.991% 2521653 2678870 2928858 3202942 3837071 4005193 4472003 4594571 4532497 4142403 3294091  
P4Approach11 6.991% 2521653 2678870 2928858 3202942 3837071 4005193 4472003 4594571 4532497 4142403 3294091  
P3Approach10 7.031% 2282093 2919470 3050280 3287880 3726202 3905795 4521532 4722345 4264141 4036148 3372733 3080694
P3Approach9 7.066% 2660268 3036249 3172291 3452274 3912512 3983911 4611963 4816792 4349424 4116871 3372733 3142308
P3Approach15 7.380% 2665208 3041788 3161875 3559061 3836633 4030649 4707520 4893098 4406020 4199174 3388118 3112332
P3Approach18 7.930% 2647228 3052306 3189068 3607462 3931143 4003440 4634570 4840404 4370745 4137052 3372733 3157711
P3Approach19 8.062% 2660268 3096974 3235737 3555842 3912512 3983911 4611963 4816792 4349424 4116871 3372733 3142308
PT RRMSE 2139899 2564937 3651846 4118761 5045301 5496303 6517808 7504235 5925288 5016674    
P3Approach3 4.119% 2171198 2580282 3362014 4418000 4838929 5277580 6376222 7545592 5961222 4832876 2923116 2609960
P3Approach7 4.134% 2129383 2584130 3324062 4364995 4813200 5293398 6413630 7610538 5998934 4836325 2921026 2600941
P3Approach14 4.313% 2171198 2631888 3429254 4506360 4838929 5277580 6376222 7545592 5961222 4832876 2923116 2609960
P3Approach20 4.313% 2171198 2631888 3429254 4506360 4838929 5277580 6376222 7545592 5961222 4832876 2923116 2609960
P3Approach4 4.477% 2205433 2622892 3373923 4495945 4957596 5452200 6606039 7838854 6178902 4981415 2921026 2678969
P3Approach2 4.514% 2169556 2453747 3238064 4178508 4864658 5261763 6338814 7480646 5923511 4829426 2925206 2618978
P3Approach12 4.684% 2172840 2635813 3390543 4539595 4813200 5293398 6413630 7610538 5998934 4836325 2921026 2600941
P3Approach5 4.821% 2216297 2635813 3390543 4583245 5053860 5425733 6573971 7800801 6148907 4957233 2921026 2665965
P3Approach17 4.900% 2129383 2635813 3390543 4583245 4813200 5293398 6413630 7610538 5998934 4836325 2921026 2600941
P3Approach1 5.007% 2172840 2461076 3165773 4079435 4813200 5293398 6413630 7610538 5998934 4836325 2921026 2600941
P3Approach13 5.022% 2169556 2627963 3467966 4649844 4864658 5261763 6338814 7480646 5923511 4829426 2925206 2618978
P3Approach9 5.048% 2212947 2679491 3535966 4694554 5107891 5366998 6465590 7630259 6041981 4926015 2925206 2671358
P3Approach8 5.179% 2202099 2640845 3484966 4716909 5132214 5393307 6497284 7667662 6071599 4950162 2925206 2684452
P3Approach10 5.486% 1898362 2576434 3399967 4471004 4864658 5261763 6338814 7480646 5923511 4829426 2925206 2618978
P4Approach5 5.616% 2212037 2542326 3269290 4251507 4944557 5042977 6022376 7447907 5990050 4656388 2688291  
P3Approach11 5.636% 2126165 2602198 3433967 4739264 4864658 5261763 6338814 7480646 5923511 4829426 2925206 2618978
P3Approach15 5.647% 2205433 2675350 3441401 4720742 4957596 5452200 6606039 7838854 6178902 4981415 2921026 2678969
P3Approach19 6.137% 2212947 2733081 3606685 4835391 5107891 5366998 6465590 7630259 6041981 4926015 2925206 2671358
P4Approach2 6.147% 2144469 2405071 3121815 4050422 4740206 5203777 6242771 7507798 5928750 4688278 2812312  
P3Approach16 6.438% 1901235 2504022 3221016 4450985 4765068 5240464 6349494 7534433 5938945 4787962 2918105 2574932
P3Approach18 6.518% 2202099 2693662 3554665 4905585 5132214 5393307 6497284 7667662 6071599 4950162 2925206 2684452
P3Approach6 6.559% 1901235 2454924 3157859 4321345 4765068 5240464 6349494 7534433 5938945 4787962 2918105 2574932
P4Approach4 6.708% 2132729 2391497 3098101 3986661 4662306 5159327 6185883 7409791 5938836 4694874 2828084  
P4Approach3 6.982% 2285474 2686368 3428621 4484473 5187859 4904402 5830424 7333600 5944082 4621199 2556383  
P4Approach1 7.047% 2285474 2686368 3428621 4484473 5187859 4904402 5830424 7540437 6148531 4621199 2556383  
RO RRMSE 924381 1031352 1041265 1236801 1622340 2056318 3266376 3623845 2198796 1674559    
P3Approach1 3.834% 975508 1008613 1103333 1211324 1646280 2051257 3264003 3564422 2149794 1806304 1591186 1240230
P3Approach6 4.211% 853570 1006092 1100575 1283156 1629817 2030744 3231363 3528778 2128296 1788241 1589595 1227828
P3Approach2 4.341% 984690 1030981 1120909 1221023 1660114 2054211 3259364 3559783 2153018 1817447 1604005 1249535
P3Approach16 4.829% 853570 1026214 1122586 1321651 1629817 2030744 3231363 3528778 2128296 1788241 1589595 1227828
P3Approach7 4.904% 955998 1059044 1158500 1296117 1646280 2051257 3264003 3564422 2149794 1806304 1591186 1240230
P3Approach3 5.515% 980099 1070787 1167727 1301306 1653197 2052734 3261684 3562102 2151406 1811876 1597596 1244882
P3Approach10 5.984% 861604 1082530 1176954 1306495 1660114 2054211 3259364 3559783 2153018 1817447 1604005 1249535
P3Approach12 6.224% 975508 1080225 1181670 1347962 1646280 2051257 3264003 3564422 2149794 1806304 1591186 1240230
P3Approach17 6.233% 955998 1080225 1181670 1360923 1646280 2051257 3264003 3564422 2149794 1806304 1591186 1240230
P3Approach14 6.405% 980099 1092203 1191082 1327332 1653197 2052734 3261684 3562102 2151406 1811876 1597596 1244882
P3Approach20 6.405% 980099 1092203 1191082 1327332 1653197 2052734 3261684 3562102 2151406 1811876 1597596 1244882
P3Approach4 6.787% 990141 1074930 1175878 1335001 1695668 2112795 3361923 3671355 2214288 1860493 1591186 1277437
P3Approach11 6.965% 964996 1093355 1188724 1384885 1660114 2054211 3259364 3559783 2153018 1817447 1604005 1249535
P3Approach13 7.136% 984690 1104181 1200493 1358755 1660114 2054211 3259364 3559783 2153018 1817447 1604005 1249535
P3Approach5 7.277% 995018 1080225 1181670 1360923 1728594 2102538 3345603 3653533 2203539 1851462 1591186 1271236
P3Approach15 8.130% 990141 1096429 1199396 1401751 1695668 2112795 3361923 3671355 2214288 1860493 1591186 1277437
P3Approach8 8.410% 999460 1109593 1206378 1378352 1751420 2105566 3340848 3648778 2206843 1862883 1604005 1280773
P3Approach9 8.734% 1004384 1125831 1224032 1371820 1743120 2095295 3324551 3630979 2196078 1853796 1604005 1274526
P3Approach18 9.723% 999460 1131785 1230506 1433486 1751420 2105566 3340848 3648778 2206843 1862883 1604005 1280773
P3Approach19 9.897% 1004384 1148348 1248513 1412975 1743120 2095295 3324551 3630979 2196078 1853796 1604005 1274526
P4Approach5 18.094% 884007 968368 1082083 1195648 1637750 2065334 2969101 1622340 2053626 1734923 1558704  
P4Approach3 18.254% 838909 971938 1104148 1222528 1696988 2136419 3108205 1622340 2021435 1677760 1517062  
P4Approach1 18.254% 838909 971938 1104148 1222528 1696988 2136419 3108205 1622340 2021435 1677760 1517062  
P4Approach2 18.359% 931445 976260 1076037 1174551 1579263 1996741 2849893 1622340 2067245 1781271 1598491  
P4Approach4 18.529% 926764 953337 1043997 1162986 1577761 1991757 2810102 1622340 2104388 1802898 1602202  
SE RRMSE 2091193 2331981 2533989 2645195 3020768 3212287 4667708 3956678 3126247 2947385    
P4Approach5 2.603% 2123627 2300663 2568990 2494854 3075237 3324635 4662643 3856208 3047669 2977648 2743206  
P4Approach10 2.603% 2123627 2300663 2568990 2494854 3075237 3324635 4662643 3856208 3047669 2977648 2743206  
P4Approach1 3.036% 2025067 2242104 2563748 2486156 3082122 3310821 4668111 3861133 3025658 2938816 2729169  
P4Approach6 3.036% 2025067 2242104 2563748 2486156 3082122 3310821 4668111 3861133 3025658 2938816 2729169  
P4Approach8 3.045% 2025067 2242104 2563748 2486156 3082122 3310821 4668111 3861133 3025658 2923816 2729169  
P4Approach3 3.045% 2025067 2242104 2563748 2486156 3082122 3310821 4668111 3861133 3025658 2923816 2729169  
P4Approach2 3.180% 2215793 2354985 2583241 2512031 3070381 3341803 4667417 3852641 3072737 3023719 2754550  
P4Approach7 3.180% 2215793 2354985 2583241 2512031 3070381 3341803 4667417 3852641 3072737 3023719 2754550  
P4Approach9 3.369% 2228581 2363459 2565224 2495074 3066324 3335092 4646931 3849925 3066626 3024239 2759936  
P4Approach4 3.369% 2228581 2363459 2565224 2495074 3066324 3335092 4646931 3849925 3066626 3024239 2759936  
P3Approach6 3.492% 1925604 2380461 2570620 2688970 3068113 3391532 4758289 3876587 3082478 3023457 2702455 2216226
P3Approach2 3.549% 2250060 2357975 2545843 2514558 3098516 3353970 4829628 3927974 3090643 2993304 2699728 2256244
P3Approach1 3.551% 2200690 2386427 2577063 2538440 3099104 3425790 4806353 3915744 3113614 3053997 2705160 2238612
P3Approach10 3.844% 1968802 2475874 2673135 2690577 3098516 3353970 4829628 3927974 3090643 2993304 2699728 2256244
P3Approach16 4.049% 1925604 2428070 2622032 2769639 3068113 3391532 4758289 3876587 3082478 3023457 2702455 2216226
P3Approach3 4.310% 2225375 2490811 2689526 2703354 3098810 3389880 4817990 3921859 3102128 3023650 2702444 2247428
P3Approach7 4.389% 2156676 2505748 2705916 2716131 3099104 3425790 4806353 3915744 3113614 3053997 2705160 2238612
P3Approach11 4.778% 2205059 2500633 2699866 2852012 3098516 3353970 4829628 3927974 3090643 2993304 2699728 2256244
P3Approach13 5.100% 2250060 2525391 2726598 2798200 3098516 3353970 4829628 3927974 3090643 2993304 2699728 2256244
P3Approach14 5.130% 2225375 2540627 2743317 2757421 3098810 3389880 4817990 3921859 3102128 3023650 2702444 2247428
P3Approach20 5.130% 2225375 2540627 2743317 2757421 3098810 3389880 4817990 3921859 3102128 3023650 2702444 2247428
P3Approach17 5.627% 2156676 2555863 2760034 2851938 3099104 3425790 4806353 3915744 3113614 3053997 2705160 2238612
P3Approach12 5.651% 2200690 2555863 2760034 2824776 3099104 3425790 4806353 3915744 3113614 3053997 2705160 2238612
P3Approach4 6.735% 2233700 2543334 2746505 2797615 3192077 3528564 4950544 4033216 3207022 3145617 2705160 2305770
P3Approach8 6.763% 2283811 2537771 2739963 2838559 3268934 3437819 4950369 4026173 3167909 3068137 2699728 2312650
P3Approach9 7.011% 2295061 2574909 2780060 2825106 3253442 3421049 4926221 4006533 3152456 3053170 2699728 2301369
P3Approach5 7.133% 2244704 2555863 2760034 2851938 3254059 3511435 4926512 4013638 3191454 3130347 2705160 2294577
P3Approach18 7.883% 2283811 2588526 2794762 2952101 3268934 3437819 4950369 4026173 3167909 3068137 2699728 2312650
P3Approach15 7.924% 2233700 2594201 2801435 2937496 3192077 3528564 4950544 4033216 3207022 3145617 2705160 2305770
P3Approach19 8.023% 2295061 2626407 2835661 2909859 3253442 3421049 4926221 4006533 3152456 3053170 2699728 2301369
SI RRMSE 452635 461157 479117 476968 560197 644661 860367 973151 680032      
P3Approach1 4.544% 433288 446588 448419 504301 579405 660356 809336 951782 645354 556666 417709 473295
P4Approach1 5.196% 418064 415219 472554 505930 571883 661052 815763 951638 693848 577259 416700  
P4Approach6 5.196% 418064 415219 472554 505930 571883 661052 815763 951638 693848 577259 416700  
P4Approach5 5.241% 416811 419286 457026 500149 568944 655714 805108 942351 674691 572585 421368  
P4Approach10 5.241% 416811 419286 457026 500149 568944 655714 805108 942351 674691 572585 421368  
P3Approach2 5.348% 424164 434918 440192 494205 572619 650949 800920 930988 640367 550959 414034 468367
P4Approach8 5.482% 418064 415219 472378 512151 576367 661052 815763 951638 701521 586947 413986  
P4Approach3 5.482% 418064 415219 472378 512151 576367 661052 815763 951638 701521 586947 413986  
P3Approach3 5.493% 428726 462790 466521 534200 576012 655652 805128 941385 642860 553812 415872 470831
P4Approach9 5.722% 416972 423826 441590 490785 562964 650866 792650 933011 651870 565531 429308  
P4Approach4 5.722% 416972 423826 441590 490785 562964 650866 792650 933011 651870 565531 429308  
P3Approach7 5.776% 424622 468917 470840 539602 579405 660356 809336 951782 645354 556666 417709 473295
P4Approach2 5.807% 414143 422880 441582 491731 564563 649887 796254 933119 651528 560603 425478  
P4Approach7 5.807% 414143 422880 441582 491731 564563 649887 796254 933119 651528 560603 425478  
P3Approach14 6.049% 428726 472046 475851 544884 576012 655652 805128 941385 642860 553812 415872 470831
P3Approach20 6.049% 428726 472046 475851 544884 576012 655652 805128 941385 642860 553812 415872 470831
P3Approach4 6.496% 439787 475951 477903 555790 596787 680167 833616 980335 664715 573366 417709 487494
P3Approach13 6.529% 424164 465797 471446 549951 572619 650949 800920 930988 640367 550959 414034 468367
P3Approach9 6.728% 432647 474931 480690 555239 601250 663968 816938 949608 653174 561978 414034 477734
P3Approach8 6.878% 430526 468081 473757 557883 604113 667223 820943 954263 656376 564733 414034 480076
P3Approach12 6.893% 433288 478295 480257 561186 579405 660356 809336 951782 645354 556666 417709 473295
P3Approach11 7.353% 415681 461231 466824 560527 572619 650949 800920 930988 640367 550959 414034 468367
P3Approach17 7.370% 424622 478295 480257 566582 579405 660356 809336 951782 645354 556666 417709 473295
P3Approach5 7.391% 441954 478295 480257 566582 608375 676865 829569 975577 661488 570583 417709 485127
P3Approach19 7.861% 432647 484430 490304 571896 601250 663968 816938 949608 653174 561978 414034 477734
P3Approach10 7.902% 371144 456664 462202 528799 572619 650949 800920 930988 640367 550959 414034 468367
P3Approach6 7.923% 379127 445471 447298 534206 573611 653752 801243 942264 638900 551099 417291 468562
P3Approach18 8.273% 430526 477443 483232 580198 604113 667223 820943 954263 656376 564733 414034 480076
P3Approach16 8.342% 379127 454380 456244 550232 573611 653752 801243 942264 638900 551099 417291 468562
P3Approach15 8.345% 439787 485470 487461 583580 596787 680167 833616 980335 664715 573366 417709 487494
SK RRMSE 652401 759001 702215 638434 760334 837791 1116684 1168657 924913 811304    
P4Approach8 3.910% 649942 744664 699068 634447 776104 834808 1004607 1096219 929535 828915 660504  
P4Approach3 3.910% 649942 744664 699068 634447 776104 834808 1004607 1096219 929535 828915 660504  
P4Approach1 3.997% 655960 746415 699068 634447 785082 840084 1005368 1099536 948310 828915 658532  
P4Approach6 3.997% 655960 746415 699068 634447 785082 840084 1005368 1099536 948310 828915 658532  
P4Approach5 6.070% 645436 721743 697017 656503 779422 821086 974884 1067760 983264 867970 697504  
P4Approach10 6.070% 645436 721743 697017 656503 779422 821086 974884 1067760 983264 867970 697504  
P3Approach2 8.050% 618718 682252 666346 673294 781505 809854 948650 1054599 992141 879109 743422 662567
P4Approach2 8.599% 637921 697946 694965 678559 778250 805630 945278 1037628 1027606 901801 743618  
P4Approach7 8.599% 637921 697946 694965 678559 778250 805630 945278 1037628 1027606 901801 743618  
P4Approach9 8.799% 637921 697946 694965 678559 778250 803822 944284 1037657 1027606 912251 727361  
P4Approach4 8.799% 637921 697946 694965 678559 778250 803822 944284 1037657 1027606 912251 727361  
P3Approach13 8.987% 618718 730692 713656 749242 781505 809854 948650 1054599 992141 879109 743422 662567
P3Approach9 9.351% 631092 745020 727650 756446 820580 826051 967623 1075691 1011984 896691 743422 675818
P3Approach8 9.533% 627999 734274 717155 760048 824488 830100 972366 1080964 1016945 901087 743422 679131
P3Approach11 9.592% 606344 723529 706660 763650 781505 809854 948650 1054599 992141 879109 743422 662567
P3Approach3 9.717% 607327 712822 720054 730624 789560 795956 930022 1035070 1014108 893142 738536 642376
P3Approach10 9.744% 541378 716365 699663 720425 781505 809854 948650 1054599 992141 879109 743422 662567
P3Approach14 10.054% 607327 727078 734455 745236 789560 795956 930022 1035070 1014108 893142 738536 642376
P3Approach20 10.054% 607327 727078 734455 745236 789560 795956 930022 1035070 1014108 893142 738536 642376
P3Approach19 10.171% 631092 759920 742203 779139 820580 826051 967623 1075691 1011984 896691 743422 675818
P3Approach18 10.568% 627999 748959 731498 790450 824488 830100 972366 1080964 1016945 901087 743422 679131
P3Approach1 10.628% 595936 675504 705186 692359 797614 782059 911394 1015542 1036076 907175 733649 622185
P3Approach7 11.409% 584017 709279 740445 740824 797614 782059 911394 1015542 1036076 907175 733649 622185
P3Approach4 11.918% 604875 719918 751552 763049 821542 805521 938736 1046008 1067158 934390 733649 640851
P3Approach12 12.015% 595936 723465 755254 770457 797614 782059 911394 1015542 1036076 907175 733649 622185
P3Approach17 12.360% 584017 723465 755254 777865 797614 782059 911394 1015542 1036076 907175 733649 622185
P3Approach5 12.425% 607855 723465 755254 777865 837495 801610 934179 1040931 1061978 929854 733649 637740
P3Approach6 12.727% 521444 673815 703423 733416 789638 774238 902280 1005387 1025715 898103 732915 615963
P3Approach16 13.047% 521444 687291 717491 755418 789638 774238 902280 1005387 1025715 898103 732915 615963
P3Approach15 13.069% 604875 734316 766583 801201 821542 805521 938736 1046008 1067158 934390 733649 640851