The aim of POLYMOD is to strengthen public
health decision-making in Europe through the
development, standardisation and application
of mathematical, risk assessment and economic
models of infectious diseases. There are four
issues that are addressed by this project. The
first is that mathematical models are only as
good as the assumptions and parameters on
which they are built.
Patterns of mixing are central determinants of
the transmission of many infections. However,
little is known about contemporary mixing
patterns. POLYMOD has therefore surveyed,
for the first time, epidemiologically relevant
contact patterns from representative samples
of eight difference European countries. These
internationally important datasets have been
supplemented by other information sources,
including serological data from a number of
different countries.
New techniques have been developed to
analyse these data, and they are already
proving invaluable in helping improve our
understanding of transmission mechanisms
and helping improve mathematical models.
Predicting the impact of control programmes
against infectious diseases requires the use of
sophisticated transmission dynamic models, as,
due to the infectious nature of the organism,
interventions often have knock-on effects
beyond those that were directly targeted.
POLYMOD has adapted and developed such
models, based on the contact pattern data, to
address a number of public health issues, such
as the impact that vaccination against varicella
may have on the epidemiology of varicella
zoster virus-related disease. In addition,
novel techniques for assessing dose-response
relationships and estimating incidence for use in
risk assessments of gastrointestinal pathogens
have been developed.
The results from models are being combined with
cost and outcome data in a series of economic
analyses to assess the cost-effectiveness of
different vaccination programmes in Europe.
Finally, the results are being presented to policymakers with the aim of helping improve
public health decision-making.
Problem:
Mathematical models are increasingly used to
estimate the impact of control programmes
against infectious diseases. The accuracy of
model predictions depends on the quality of
the data used to parameterise them. Contact
patterns between individuals are critical to
the spread of many infectious diseases (e.g.
as influenza, TB, smallpox, meningitis etc).
However, very little is known about the relevant
contact patterns. Instead, analysts have
assumed certain contact patterns based on
very little (or no) data. Clearly, this affects the
reliability of predictions and the policy advice
that follows from this.
POLYMOD aims to collect relevant contact
pattern data, improve mathematical models,
use these models in economic analysis, and
then convey the results to policymakers.
Aim:
To improve public health decision-making,
through improved mathematical models of the
spread of infectious diseases.
Results:
Highlights of the results are presented here.
Figure 1. Age-specific contact matrices for different
European countries. White colour indicates high contact
rates, green intermediate contact rates and blue colour
indicates low contact rates, relative to the countryspecific
contact intensity. Data were presented in
Mossong et al., PLoS Medicine, 2008.
Figure 1 summarises the age-dependency in
contact patterns observed in the eight different
countries that performed a survey. It is clear that
contact patterns tend to be highly correlated
with respect to age (people tend to contact
others that are similar in age to themselves)
and that this is particularly true for children and
young adults. This has particularly important
implications for vaccination programmes, which
are often targeted at one age group, but may
have an impact on other ages. Furthermore, it
is very important for understanding the spread
of emerging pathogens, such as pandemic influenza, and the potential impact of various
control measures, including school closure. It
is also very noticeable that contact patterns
are similar in different European countries,
suggesting that it may be able to extrapolate
from these surveys to other countries. Full
details of the results are given in Mossong et
al. 'Social contacts and mixing patterns relevant
to the spread of infectious diseases', PLoS
Med, 2008, Mar 25;5(3):e71.
Utilising these contact patterns new models
of VZV transmission have been developed
and have been used to predict the impact of
vaccination. The results of these models are
being fed into economic analyses, and are
being presented to decision-makers.
Figure 2. The estimated cost-effectiveness of rotavirus
vaccination in 5 different European countries (data from
Jit et al. unpublished).
Figure 2 gives an example of the costeffectiveness
of rotavirus vaccination in
a number of different countries (Jit et al.,
unpublished). The results suggest that rotavirus
vaccination may not be cost-effective at current
vaccine prices.
Potential applications:
POLYMOD should lead to improved decisionmaking
in the area of infectious disease
control. The results generated are directly
applicable to a wide range of diseases, including
gastrointestinal diseases, vaccine-preventable
diseases, and emerging infectious diseases,
such as pandemic influenza.
Coordinator:
Partners:
Pierre van Damme
UA-UIA Centrum voor
de Evaluatie van Vaccinaties
Universitaire Instelling Antwerpen (UIA)
Antwerp, Belgium
Petrus Franciscus Maria Teunis
National Institute of Public
Health and the Environment (RIVM)
Bilthoven, Netherlands
Auranen Kari
National Public Health Institute (KTL)
Helsinki, Finland
Joel Mossong
Laboratoire National de Santé
Luxembourg, Luxembourg
Stefania Salmaso
The Communicable Disease Epidemiology
Unit (CDEU) at Istituto Superiore di Sanit
Rome, Italy
Marc Aerts
Centre for Statistics
Hasselt University
Diepenbeek, Belgium
Mirjam Kretzschmar
Department of Public Health Medicine
School of Public Health
University of Bielefeld
Bielefeld, Germany
Joanna Siennicka
Departments of Virology and Epidemiology
of National Institute of Hygiene
Warsaw, Poland
Conor Patrick Farrington
Open University
Department of Statistics
Milton Keynes, UK
Piero Manfredi
Università di Pisa
Dipartimento di Statistica e Matematica
Applicata all'Economia
Pisa, Italy
Gianpaolo Scalia Tomba
Universita degli studi di Roma Tor Vergata
Dipartimento di Matematica
Rome, Italy
Benot Dervaux
Centre de Recherches en Economie,
Sociologie et Gestion (CRESGE)
Lille, France
Rose-Marie Carlsson
Swedish Institute for Infectious Disease
Control (SMI)
Solna Municipality, Sweden
Daniel Levy-Bruhl
Institut de Veille Sanitaire (National
Institute for Public Health Surveillance),
(InVS) Saint-Maurice, France
Francesco Candeloro Billari
Istituto di Metodi Quantitativi (IMQ)
Università Commerciale Luigi Bocconi
Milan, Italy