Replies to the Consultation Paper on the
Patentability of Computer-Implemented Inventions
On 19 October 2000, the European Commission launched consultations via
the Internet on the patentability of computer-implemented inventions.
Interested parties, the public at large and Member States were invited to
comment by 15 December 2000 on the basis of a consultation paper. The aim
of the consultation is to help the Commission to identify the best
approach to the issue so as to strike the right balance between promoting
innovation and ensuring adequate competition in the market place. At the
top of that webpage, those commenting on the Commission's consultation
paper were asked to indicate whether or not they agreed to their comments
being published by the Commission, either "as is", or without their name,
address etc. Answers from authors who have agreed to publication are being
reproduced below.
In the context of the Commission's consultation, a great number of
comments were sent to
consultation@eurolinux.org and published. Copies of such comments have
been received by DG Internal Market. This webpage was set up by the
EuroLinux Alliance of software publishers and non-profit organisations.
The EuroLinux Alliance indicates on that webpage that it has created a
public forum and asks European consumers, European IT professionals and
European companies to send public statements, reports and position papers
on software patents to consultation@eurolinux.org. The EuroLinux Alliance
further states that e-mails sent to that address are automatically being
published on their above webpage and forwarded to DG Internal Market. In
line with the notice at the top of the Commission's webpage mentioned in
the first paragraph, comments sent to consultation@eurolinux.org and
forwarded to the Commission are published below only where their authors
have expressly agreed to such publication by the Commission.
Furthermore, the United Kingdom Patent Office carried out a
consultation on the question as to whether or not patents should be
granted for computer software or ways of doing business. For further
information, please visit the website of the
UK Patent
Office.
Replies:
- Comments
of Software & Information Industry Association (SIIA), Washington (DC)
- 14.11.2001 (PDF file, 21KB)
- Muriel,
Manuel - 28.02.2001 (PDF file, 12 KB)
- The
EU Committee of the American Chamber of Commerce in Belgium -
12.01.2001 (PDF file, 11 KB)
- EICTA
European Information and Communications Technology Industry Association
- 05.01.2001 (PDF file, 44 KB)
- IBM
Europe - 04.01.2001 (PDF file, 38 KB)
- BSA
Business Software Alliance - 03.01.2001 (PDF file, 27 KB)
- IS
Internet Society France - 18.12.2000 (PDF file, 53 KB)
- Max-Planck-Institut
für ausländisches und internationales Patent-, Urheber- und
Wettbewerbsrecht, München - 18.12.2000 (PDF file, 1.124
KB)
- Gonzalez
Barahona, Jesus M. - 16.12.2000 (PDF file, 21 KB)
- Anonymous
- 15.12.2000 (PDF file, 11 KB)
- Association
Internationale pour la protection de la Propriété industrielle
15.12.2000 (PDF file, 30 KB) / Rapport
- ASPI
Association des Spécialistes en Propriété Industrielle
de l'Industrie, Paris - 15.12.2000 (PDF file, 21 KB)
- BILETA
The British and Irish Law, Education and Technology Association
- 15.12.2000 (PDF file, 14 KB)
- Bjerke,
Flemming - 15.12.2000 (PDF file, 9 KB)
- CLEDIPA
Comité de Liaison Européen de la Distribution Indépendante
de Pièces de rechange et Equipements pour Automobiles -
15.12.2000 (PDF file, 9 KB)
- EISA
European IT Services Association - Harrison, Laurence - 15.12.2000
(PDF file, 19 KB)
- ICL
PLC - 15.12.2000 (PDF file 25 KB)
- KLID
- Kommercielle Linux Interessenter i Danmark - 15.12.2000 (PDF
file, 9 KB)
- Pettiaux,
Nicolas - 15.12.2000 (PDF file, 7 KB)
- FICPI
- Fédération Internationale des Conseils en Propriété
Industrielle - 15.12.2000 (PDF file, 48 KB)
- Österreichische
Vereinigung für gewerblichen Rechtsschutz und Urheberrecht
- 15.12.200 (PDF file, 16 KB)
- Studierende
der Universitaet des Saarlandes - 15.12.2000 (PDF file, 5 KB)
- UNICE
The voice of Business Europe - 15.12.2000 (PDF file, 21 KB)
- Watts,
Richard - 15.12.2000 (PDF file, 108 KB)
- BBC
British Broadcasting Corporation, London - 14.12.2000 (PDF file,
12 KB)
- Bull
SA - 14.12.2000 (PDF file, 25 KB)
- Gesellschaft
für Informatik e.V - 14.12.2000 (PDF file, 42 KB)
- Jensen,
Niels K. - 14.12.2000 (PDF file, 5 KB)
- Maitland
Kalton - 14.12.2000 (PDF file, 36 KB)
- Michelet,
Alain - 14.12.2000 (PDF file, 43 KB)
- van
Dijk, Luuk - 14.12.2000 (PDF file, 22 KB)
- Tange,
Ole (DKUUG) - 14.12.2000 (PDF file, 26 KB)
- Trade
Marks Patents & Design Federation, London - 14.12.2000 (PDF
file, 16 KB)
- Hands,
Philip - 13.12.2000 (PDF file, 12 KB)
- SYNTEC
INFORMATIC Chambre Syndicale des SSII et des Éditeurs de logiciels
- 13.12.2000 (PDF file, 17 KB)
- Laboratoire
Bordelais de Recherche en Informatique - Castanet, Richard -
12.12.2000 (PDF file, 22 KB)
- Tange,
Ole - 12.12.2000 (PDF file, 6 KB)
- Federation
of the Electronics Industry - 11.12.2000 (PDF file, 32 KB)
- Breese,
Pierre - 10.12.2000 (PDF file, 33 KB)
- Nissoux,
Jean-Louis - 07.12.2000 (PDF file, 5 KB)
- Rechtsanwälte
Kiani & Springorum - 07.12.2000 (PDF file, 12 KB)
- Widenius,
Michael - 05.12.2000 (PDF file, 16 KB)
- ALCATEL
- 04.12.2000 (PDF file, 31 KB)
- Freischem,
Stephan, European Patent and Trademark Attorney - 04.12.2000
(PDF file, 15 KB)
- France
Telecom - 12.2000 (PDF file, 27 KB)
- Professor
Joaquin Seoane/Ramón García
- 12.2000 (PDF file, 94 KB)
- Endres,
A. - 28.11.2000 (PDF file, 13 KB)
- Avis,
Edward - 24.11.2000 (PDF file, 19 KB)
- Rechtsanwalt
Trapp, Andreas - 22.11.2000 (PDF file, 5 KB)
- Anonymous
- 20.11.2000 (PDF file, 7 KB)
- Calvet,
Axel - 20.11.2000 (PDf file, 5 KB)
- Demoulin,
J-Brice - 15.11.2000 (PDF file, 6 KB)
- Eriksson,
Jakob - 15.11.2000 (PDF file, 4 KB)
- Anonymous
- 09.11.200 (PDF file, 5 KB)
- Malde,
Ketil - 09.11.2000 (PDF file, 6 KB)
- Smile,
Alan - 02.11.2000 (PDF file, 4 KB)
- Short,
Justin - 31.10.2000 (PDF file, 7 KB)
- Oksanen,
Ville - 30.10.2000 (PDF file, 7 KB)
- Markham,
Gervase - 29.10.2000 (PDF file, 7 KB)
- Zander,
Thomas (1) - 29.10.2000 (PDF file, 9 KB)
- Zander,
Thomas (2) - 29.10.2000 (PDF file, 5 KB)
- Chown,
Peter - 28.10.2000 (PDF file, 6 KB)
- Roth,
Magnus - 28.10.2000 (PDF file, 4 KB)
- Schaffert,
Sebastian - 28.10.2000 (PDF file, 5 KB)
- Zander,
Thomas (3) - 28.10.2000 (PDF file, 15 KB)
- Anonymous
- 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 7 KB)
- Anonymous
- 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 44 KB)
- Bruyninckx,
Herman - 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 10 KB)
- Ferran,
Xavier - 27.10.1000 (PDF file, 52 KB)
- Holemans,
Didier - 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 8 KB)
- Internet
Society Luxembourg (ASBL) - 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 6 KB)
- Isaac,
Alan - 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 5 KB)
- Lakofski
- 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 5 KB)
- Liebart,
Dominique - 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 7 KB)
- McIninch,
James - 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 7 KB)
- Roedding,
Daniel - 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 6 KB)
- Rue,
Tim - 27.10.2000 (PDf file, 10 KB)
- Selig,
Christian - 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 9 KB)
- Yerrik,
Damian - 27.10.2000 (PDF file, 5 KB)
- Agopoglu
- 26.10.2000 (PDF file, 5KB)
- Causton,
Raymond - 26.10.2000 (PDF file, 7 KB)
- Clerc,
Maurice - 26.10.2000 (PDF file, 6 KB)
- Hoevekamp,
Tobias - 26.10.2000 (PDF file, 10 KB)
- Moens,
Annelis - 26.10.2000 (PDF file, 4 KB)
- Luguet,
Grégory - 26.10.2000 (PDF file, 7 KB)
- Rodriguez,
Mathias - 26.10.2000 (PDF file, 7 KB)
- Smets,
Jean-Paul - 26.10.2000 (PDF file, 14 KB)
- Longo,
Nick - 20.10.2000 (PDF file, 6 KB)
- Basinsky,
Erwin (PDF file, 17 KB)
- Clerc,
Pierre (PDF file, 9KB)
- Darche,
Marc-Aurèle; Rousset, Paul; Dr. Darche, Armelle; Buard, Jeanine;
Darche, Christiane (PDF file: 26 KB)
- European
Affairs Office, GE International (PDF file, 16 KB)
- GE
Global eXchange Service (PDF file, 28 KB)
- Higgins,
Amy (PDF file, 11 KB)
- Hössle
& Kudlek (PDF file, 57 KB)
- Geer,
Benjamin (PDF file, 8 KB)
- Philips
(PDF file, 12 KB)
- Schölch,
Günther (PDF file, 26 KB)
- University
of Maryland, College of Information Studies/Center for Information Policy,
Kahin, Brian (PDF file, 28 KB)
EuroLinux Alliance
- Official
response - Core (PDF file: 53 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 1 (PDF file: 178 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 17 (PDF file: 57 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 19 (PDF file: 32 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 21 (PDF file: 53 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 22 (PDF file: 40 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 23 (PDF file: 329 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 24 (PDF file: 200 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 31 (PDF file: 56 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 38 (PDF file: 446 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 39 (PDF file: 56 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 44 (PDF file: 57 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 45 (PDF file: 21 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 46 (PDF file: 25 KB)
- Official
response - Appendix 50 (PDF file: 71 KB)
|