2.8.1. Appointment and Composition
Tenders are opened and evaluated by an evaluation committee formally and promptly appointed by the contracting authority comprising a non-voting chairperson, a non-voting secretary and an odd number of voting members (the evaluators).
There must be a minimum of three evaluators for all procedures except for calls for tenders for works above EUR 5 000 000, which require a minimum of five of them.
Evaluators must be provided with detailed information regarding the planned timetable and the workload that the evaluation implies.
The contracting authority shall make sure that evaluators are available during the scheduled evaluation period. The contracting authority will appoint a replacement evaluator for each procedure to prevent delays in case of unavailability.
Every member must have reasonable command of the language in which the tenders are submitted. Evaluators must have the technical and administrative ability to give an informed opinion on the tenders. Their identity is confidential.
Members of the evaluation committee (i.e. the chairperson, the secretary and the evaluators) are appointed on a personal basis by the relevant European Commission services which also approve any observer. For procurement procedures, a representative of the beneficiary country may participate as appropriate, either as an evaluator or as an observer. In grant procedures, a representative of the beneficiary country may participate as an observer, or in the case of EDF, as an evaluator.
INDIRECT MANAGEMENT WITH EX-ANTE CONTROLS:
The members of the evaluation committee (i.e. the chairperson, the secretary and the evaluators) are appointed on a personal basis by the contracting authority and the appointments are submitted in due time to the European Commission in order to get its approval. If the European Commission does not object within five working days, the committee is deemed to be approved. The European Commission must be invited to appoint an observer and is encouraged to attend all or part of the meetings. Independent experts recruited under service contracts may only attend as observers. Attendance by other observers requires prior approval by the European Commission.
INDIRECT MANAGEMENT WITH EX-POST CONTROLS:
The members of the evaluation committee (i.e. the chairperson, the secretary and the evaluators) are appointed on a personal basis by the relevant services, which also approve any observers. Independent experts recruited under service contracts may only attend as observers.
Evaluation committee members must attend all meetings. Any absence must be recorded and explained in the evaluation report.
All evaluators have equal voting rights.
An evaluation committee must be established for all procurement procedures, with the exception of the single tender one (less than or equal to EUR 20 000). For grants procedures, see section 6.5.7. and section 6.4.2.
For consultation procedures under a framework contract, the guidelines of that specific framework contract should be followed.