Energy

Market legislation

Market legislation

Overview

The latest round of EU energy market legislation, known as the third package, has been enacted to improve the functioning of the internal energy market and resolve structural problems. It covers five main areas:

  • unbundling energy suppliers from network operators
  • strengthening the independence of regulators
  • establishment of the Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators (ACER)
  • cross-border cooperation between transmission system operators and the creation of European Networks for Transmission System Operators
  • increased transparency in retail markets to benefit consumers

Unbundling

Unbundling is the separation of energy supply and generation from the operation of transmission networks. If a single company operates a transmission network and generates or sells energy at the same time, it may have an incentive to obstruct competitors' access to infrastructure. This prevents fair competition in the market and can lead to higher prices for consumers.

Under the third package, unbundling must take place in one of three ways, depending on the preferences of individual EU countries:

  • Ownership Unbundling where all integrated energy companies sell off their gas and electricity networks. In this case, no supply or production company is allowed to hold a majority share or interfere in the work of a transmission system operator
  • Independent System Operator where energy supply companies may still formally own gas or electricity transmission networks but must leave the entire operation, maintenance, and investment in the grid to an independent company
  • Independent Transmission System Operator where energy supply companies may still own and operate gas or electricity networks but must do so through a subsidiary. All important decisions must be taken independent of the parent company

The European Commission publishes guidance documents which explain how these unbundling models should be applied:

Ownership unbundling: assessing conflicts of interests [SWD(2013) 177]

Implementation note on unbundling in the Electricity Directive and the Natural Gas Directive

Interpretive note on third-party access to storage facilities in the Electricity Directive and the Natural Gas Directive

Operators that comply with the unbundling rules can apply for certification with their national energy regulator. Every operator in Europe must be certified and the Commission provides its opinion on the certification procedure. These opinions are found here:

Opinions and decisions on operator certifications

List of certification notifications received

Certification of Transmission System Operators of networks for electricity and natural gas in the EU [SEC(2011) 1095]

Independent regulators

A competitive internal energy market cannot exist without independent regulators who ensure the application of the rules. Under the third package, the requirements for national regulators have undergone a number of changes. Specifically:

  • regulators must be independent from both industry interests and government. They must be their own legal entity and have authority over their own budget. National governments must also supply them with sufficient resources to carry out their operations
  • regulators can issue binding decisions to companies and impose penalties on those that do not comply with their legal obligations
  • electricity generators, gas network operators, and energy suppliers are required to provide accurate data to regulators
  • regulators from different EU countries must cooperate with each other to promote competition, the opening-up of the market, and an efficient and secure energy network system

Interpretive note on regulatory authorities in the Electricity Directive and the Natural Gas Directive

Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators

In order to help the different national regulators cooperate and ensure the smooth functioning of the internal energy market, the EU established the Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators (ACER). ACER is independent from the Commission, national governments, and energy companies. Its work involves:

  • drafting guidelines for the operation of cross-border gas pipelines and electricity networks
  • reviewing the implementation of EU-wide network development plans
  • deciding on cross-border issues if national regulators cannot agree or if they ask it to intervene
  • monitoring the functioning of the internal market including retail prices, network access for electricity produced from renewables, and consumer rights

ACER website

Commission Evaluation of ACER

Paper on the Possibility of Neighboring Countries and their Transmission System Operators to Participate in ACER and in the ENTSOs [SEC(2011)546]

ACER call for Board of Appeal members

Cross-border cooperation

National transmission system operators are responsible for ensuring electricity and natural gas is effectively transported through pipelines and grids.

Due to the cross-border nature of Europe's energy market, they must work together to ensure the optimal management of EU networks. This is done through the European Network for Transmission System Operators for Electricity (ENTSO-E) and the European Network for Transmission System Operators for Gas (ENTSOG).

These organisations:

  • develop standards and draft network codes to help harmonise the flow of electricity and gas across different transmission systems
  • coordinate the planning of new network investments and monitor the development of new transmission capabilities. This includes publishing a Europe-wide 10 year investment plan to help identify investment gaps every two years.

ENTSO-E website

ENTSO-G website

Open and fair retail markets

The third package includes rules designed to benefit European energy consumers and protect their rights. They include the right to choose or change suppliers without extra charges, receive information on energy consumption, and quickly and cheaply resolve disputes.

Interpretive note on the retail market in the Electricity Directive and the Natural Gas Directive

More on consumer rights

Share this page