Navigation path

HOME
Policy areas
Sectors
About competition policy
Cases & legislation
Current Issues
Contacts
In this section:
Overview
National Court judgments
Requests for information/opinion
Amicus curiae
Training of national judges
Actions for damages
Contacts

Cooperation with national courts (Antitrust)

Application of Competition rules by national courts
– Article 15 (2)

Antitrust


National courts cases - France

2014

 
Judgment date: 13.03.2014
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 2013/00714
Parties: AUTORITE DE LA CONCURRENCE / BANG & OLUFSEN
Type of proceeding: modifying NCA decision
Sector: Consumer products
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf

2013

 
Judgment date: 24.09.2013
Court name: Cour de cassation
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 882 FS-P+B
Parties: CDM - société Compagnie de diététique du marin / CDS société Caribéenne de diététique et santé / Les Laboratoires dermatologiques Avène / Les Laboratoires dermatologiques Ducray / Les laboratoires Klorane / Les laboratoires dermatologiques Galénic / MAD - société Martinique alimentation diététique / Pierre Fabre dermo-cosmétique et Pierre Fabre Médicament / René Furterer
Type of proceeding: damages action / finding of (partial) nullity
Sector: Consumer products
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 26.06.2013
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 12/04441
Parties: Société JCB SALES LTD, JCB BAMFORD EXCAVATORS LTD, JCB SERVICE / SA CENTRAL PARTS
Type of proceeding: damages action
Sector: Manufacturing
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 11.06.2013
Court name: Cour de cassation
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 614 FS-P+B
Parties: Beauté prestige international / Chanel / Clarins fragrance group / Comptoir nouveau de la parfumerie - Hermès / Elco / Guerlain / L'Autorité de la concurrence, DGCCRF, / L'Oréal produits de luxe France / LVMH Fragrance Brands / La société Marionnaud parfumerie / Nocibé France / Parfums Christian Dior / Sephora / Shiseido Europe / Yves Saint Laurent beauté
Type of proceeding: annulling NCA decision / up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Consumer products
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 16.05.2013
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 2012/01227
Parties: KONTIKI S.A.S.
Type of proceeding: up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Consumer products
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 16.04.2013
Court name: Cour de cassation
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: H1014881
Parties: Expedia Inc. / VFE commerce / Voyages-sncf.com / iDTGV
Type of proceeding: up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Other services 
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 28.03.2013
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 2011/18245
Parties: CHEVRON PRODUCTS COMPANY / DES PÉTROLES SHELL
Type of proceeding: up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Energy (electricity, gas and water supply), Transport
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf

2012

 
Judgment date: 29.03.2012
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 2011/01228
Parties: FRANCHE COMTE SIGNAUX; LAPORTE SERVICE ROUTE S.A.S. / LACROIX SIGNALISATION, S.A.S. - SECURITE ET SIGNALISATION, S.A.S. - SELARL - AXIMUM, S.A. / SELAR AJ PARTENAIRES; SIGNATURE S.A. / SIGNAUX GIROD; SODILOR S.A.S. / l'AUTORITE DE LA CONCURRENCE
Type of proceeding: Other / modifying NCA decision / up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Manufacturing
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 20.03.2012
Court name: Cour de cassation
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: F1016329
Parties: ATRIUM SANTE SOCIETE / PIERRE FABRE DERMO-COSMETIQUE
Type of proceeding: injunction (e.g. claims for payment or contractual obligations)
Sector: Consumer products, Manufacturing
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 23.02.2012
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 2010/20555
Parties: ADUMP, UFC - QUE CHOISIR / BNP PARIBAS SA – BPCE SA – CREDIT AGRICOLE SA – CREDIT DU NORD SA – HSBC FRANCE SA / CREDIT LYONNAIS- LA CONFEDERATION NATIONALE DU CREDIT MUTUEL - LA SOCIETE GENERALE S.A. - LA BANQUE POSTALE, S.A. - La societe LE CREDIT INDUSTRIEL ET COMMERCIAL, S.A.
Type of proceeding: Other / modifying NCA decision
Sector: Financial services
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 31.01.2012
Court name: Cour de cassation
Court town: Paris
Reference number: 140
Parties: Digicel Antilles / France Telecom / L'Autorite de la Concurrence / Minister de l'Economie, de l'Industrie et de l'Emploi / Orange Caraibe / Outremer Telecom
Type of proceeding: other
Sector: Telecom & Post
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 26.01.2012
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 2010/23945
Parties: AUTORITE DE LA CONCURRENCE / BEAUTE PRESTIGE INTERNATIONAL - CHANEL - CLARINS FRAGRANCE GROUP - HERMES PARFUMS - PARFUMS CHRISTIAN DIOR / ELCO - GUERLAIN - LVMH FRAGRANCE BRANDS - L'OREAL - SHISEIDO EUROPE - YVES SAINT LAURENT BEAUTE - MARIONNAUD PARFUMERIE - NOCIBE FRANCE - SEPHORA
Type of proceeding: modifying NCA decision
Sector: Consumer products
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 17.01.2012
Court name: Cour de cassation
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 58 FS-P+B - Pourvoi F 11-13.067
Parties: France Telecom / SFR
Type of proceeding: other
Sector: Telecom & Post
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf

2011

 
Judgment date: 14.12.2011
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Reference number: 09/20639
Parties: British airways / Compagnie Emirates / S.A.R.L. CHADEP
Type of proceeding: Other / other
Sector: Transport
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 12.07.2011
Court name: Cour de cassation
Court town: Paris
Reference number: 806 FS-P+B
Parties: LAFARGE / VICAT
Type of proceeding: up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Construction
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 30.06.2011
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 2010/12049
Parties: ORANGE FRANCE
Type of proceeding: up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Telecom & Post
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 29.03.2011
Court name: Cour de cassation
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: T1012913 (AROB)
Parties: ADDECO FRANCE / MANPOWER FR
Type of proceeding: up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Other services 
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 01.03.2011
Court name: Cour de cassation
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: J0972655(AROB) Arret 200 FS-P+B
Parties: AIR FRANCE / TOTAL FINA ELF, AIR TOTAL INTERNATIONAL, SHELL, EXXON MOBIL AVIATION INTERNATIONAL, TEXACO LIMITED
Type of proceeding: annulling NCA decision / other
Sector: Energy (electricity, gas and water supply), Transport
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 27.01.2011
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Reference number: 2010/17418
Parties: L'AUTORITE DE LA CONCURRENCE / M. Jean-Michel QUIE
Type of proceeding: up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Public administration (including education, health & social work)
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 20.01.2011
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Reference number: 2010/08165
Parties: A.P.MOLLER-MAERSK A/S / L'AUTORITE DE LA CONCURRENCE / PERRIGAULT SA; TERMINALPORTE OCEANE TPO SA
Type of proceeding: Other / modifying NCA decision
Sector: Transport
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf

2010

 
Judgment date: 02.09.2010
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: COLMAR
Reference number: 09/02844
Parties: Inst Prévoyance / Patisserie Marx
Type of proceeding: other
Sector: Other services 
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 18.08.2010
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: VERSAILLES
Reference number:
Parties: Fédération des Syndicats de la Distribution / Fédération nationale de l'artisanat automobile / SAS Renault
Type of proceeding: injunction (e.g. claims for payment or contractual obligations)
Sector: Motor vehicles
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 13.07.2010
Court name: Cour de cassation
Court town: Paris
Reference number: X0813944/ 861FS-P+B
Parties: AB Electrolux / Atlantic / Babyliss / Calor / De Dietrich / De Dietrich Thermique / De'Longhi SPA / Divelit Holding / Electrolux Home Products France / Electrolux Lda / Fagor Electrodomesticos S Coop / Fagor Ireland Ltd. / Google France / Google Inc / Groupement Interprofessionel des fabricants d'Appareils d'Equipement ménager (GIFAM) / Hoover Italiana SPA / Indesit / Kenwood Marks Ltd. / Liebherr int AG / M & B Marchi E Brevetti SRL / Magimix / Miele & cie Gmbh / Robert Krups Gmbh / Rowenta-Werke Gmbh / SEB / SMEG SPA / SRL Candy Elettrodomestici / Saeco / Whirlpool France / Whirlpool Properties Inc
Type of proceeding: injunction (e.g. claims for payment or contractual obligations)
Sector: Media
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 15.06.2010
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 2009/20624
Parties: Keolis / Transdev / Veolia Transport
Type of proceeding: up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Transport
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 26.01.2010
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 2009/03532
Parties: ADIA / Adecco / EDF / Manpower / Randstad
Type of proceeding: up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Other services 
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf

2009

 
Judgment date: 24.11.2009
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 2009/00315
Parties: Air France / Chevron / Esso / Shell / Total
Type of proceeding: up-holding NCA decision
Sector: Energy (electricity, gas and water supply), Transport
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 29.10.2009
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Reference number: 2008/23812
Parties: PFDC / PIERRE FABRE, DERMOCOSMETIQUE, S.A.S
Type of proceeding:
Sector: Manufacturing
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 27.10.2009
Court name: Tribunal de Grande Instance
Court town: PARIS
Reference number: 08/02097
Parties: AG2R PREVOYANCE / S.A.R.L. BEAUDOUT PERE ET FILS
Type of proceeding: request for preliminary ruling
Sector: Food
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf

2008

 
Judgment date: 18.04.2008
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Reference number: 07/04360
Parties: PMC Distribution SARL / Pacific Creation SAS
Type of proceeding: Other procedural issues
Sector: Manufacturing
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf

2007

 
Judgment date: 29.05.2007
Court name: Tribunal de Commerce
Court town: Paris
Reference number: 2006072651
Parties: IDEXX LABORATORIES INC SARL IDEXX IDEXX EUROPE BV ORTHO CLINICAL DIAGNOSTICS INC / SARL MANO MEDICAL
Type of proceeding: injunction (e.g. claims for payment or contractual obligations)
Sector: Pharmaceuticals
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 24.05.2007
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Versailles
Reference number: 217
Parties: IDEXX LABORATOIRES SARL IDEXX / SARL MANO MEDICAL
Type of proceeding: injunction (e.g. claims for payment or contractual obligations)
Sector: Pharmaceuticals
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 06.02.2007
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Versailles
Reference number: 06/3390
Parties: IDEXX LABORATOIRES IDEXX / SARL MANO MEDICAL
Type of proceeding: injunction (e.g. claims for payment or contractual obligations)
Sector: Pharmaceuticals
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf

2006

 
Judgment date: 22.09.2006
Court name: Tribunal de Commerce
Court town: Versailles
Reference number: 2005F05555
Parties: SARL MANO MEDICAL / STE IDEXX LABORATORIES INC SARL IDEXX IDEXX EUROPE BV ORTHO CLINICAL DIAGNOSTICS
Type of proceeding: injunction (e.g. claims for payment or contractual obligations)
Sector: Pharmaceuticals
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 31.03.2006
Court name: Tribunal de Commerce
Court town: Versailles
Reference number: 2004F06266
Parties: IDEXX LABORATOIRES IDEXX / SARL MANO MEDICAL
Type of proceeding: injunction (e.g. claims for payment or contractual obligations)
Sector: Pharmaceuticals
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 25.01.2006
Court name: Tribunal de Commerce
Court town: Versailles
Reference number: 2004F06266
Parties: IDEXX LABORATOIRES IDEXX / SARL MANO MEDICAL
Type of proceeding:
Sector: Pharmaceuticals
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 25.01.2006
Court name: Tribunal de Commerce
Court town: Versailles
Reference number: 2005F05555
Parties: SARL IDEXX IDEXX EUROPE BV ORTHO CLINICAL DIAGNOSTICS INC / SARL MANO MEDICAL
Type of proceeding: injunction (e.g. claims for payment or contractual obligations)
Sector: Pharmaceuticals
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf

2004

 
Judgment date: 16.06.2004
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Versailles
Reference number: 419
Parties: IDEXX LABORATOIRES / SARL MANO MEDICAL
Type of proceeding: injunction (e.g. claims for payment or contractual obligations)
Sector: Pharmaceuticals
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 07.01.2004
Court name: Tribunal de Commerce
Court town: Versailles
Reference number: 2003R00795
Parties: IDEXX LABORATORIES INC / SARL MANO MEDICAL
Type of proceeding: injunction (e.g. claims for payment or contractual obligations)
Sector: Pharmaceuticals
Decision: [Final Judgment] pdf
   
Judgment date: 28.08.2007
Court name: Cour d'Appel de Pau
Court town: Pau
Reference number: 06/309/
Parties: SAS PRIM'CO against SCA MADROUQUES,SCEA CANTEGRIT
Type of proceeding: Private litigation
Sector: Food
Decision: Appeal pdf
   
Judgment date: 29.06.2007
Court name: Cour de Cassation
Court town: Paris
Reference number: No 1020 FS-P+B+I
Parties: Bouygues Télécom, SFR, Orange
Type of proceeding: Against Competition Authority
Sector: Telecommunication
Decision: Partial annulment pdf
   
Judgment date: 22.06.2007
Court name: Tribunal de Commerce de Nanterre
Court town: Nanterre
Reference number: 206F4453
Parties: SA Concurrence againt Sony France
Type of proceeding: Private litigation
Sector: Audiovisuel
Decision: Contradictory decision pdf
   
Judgment date: 07.06.2007
Court name: Cour d'appel de Paris
Court town: Paris
Reference number: 188/07
Parties: S.A.S GARAGE GREMAEAU against DAIMLER CHRYSLER FRANCE
Type of proceeding: Private litigation
Sector: Automobile
Decision: Interlocutory decision pdf
   
Judgment date: 01.06.2007
Court name: Tribunal de Commerce de Nanterre
Court town: Nanterre
Reference number: 2005F00945
Parties: SA Laboratoire Biorga France c/ SARL C & RF - Italie
Type of proceeding: Private litigation
Sector: Pharmaceutical
Decision: First instance decision- contradictory jugment pdf
   
Judgment date: 11.05.2007
Court name: Tribunal de Commerce de Nanterre
Court town: Nanterre
Reference number: 2004F2643
Parties: Arkopharmac/Roche
Type of proceeding: Private litigation
Sector: Pharmaceutical
Decision: First instance decision-jugment after trial pdf
   
Judgment date: 23.01.2007
Court name: Cour d'Appel de Paris
Court town: Paris
Reference number: No 4
Parties: Société PHARM-LAB, S.A.R.L
Type of proceeding: Private litigation
Sector: Pharmaceuticals
Decision: Rejection of appeal pdf
 
Judgment date: 12.12.2006
Court name: Cour d'Appel de Paris
Court town: Paris
Reference number: 33
Parties Appeal: Bouygues Télécom, SA; SFR, SA; Orange France, SA; Cross-appeal: UFC-Que Choisir
Type of proceeding: Appeal (against the decision of the Conseil de la Concurrence)
Sector: Telecommunications
Decision: Rejection of appeal pdf
 
Judgment date: 10.05.2006
Court name: Cour de Cassation
Court town: Paris
Parties: ETNA France/France Télécom SA et Société Française de Radiotéléphone (SFR)
Type of proceeding: Private litigation
Sector: Telecommunications
Decision: Appeal pdf
 
Judgment date: 07.02.2006
Court name: Cour de Cassation
Court town: Paris
Parties: TRANSDEV, KEOLIS & CONNEX
Type of proceeding: Judicial review of NCA decision
Sector: Public transport
Decision: Appeal pdf
 
Judgment date: 16.01.2006
Court name: Cour de Cassation
Court town: Paris
Parties: SPEA, Peugeot
Type of proceeding: Decision of a NCA (second appeal)
Sector: Motor vehicle sector
Decision: Appeal
 
Judgment date: 14.12.2005
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: Etablissements Ginoux SA / Automobiles Peugeot, HPA & Moulin
Decision: Appeal Decision pdf
 
Judgment date: 21.09.2005
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: Socovi Sarl Société de Coiffure Vichyssoise / Jean-Louis David France SA
Decision: Appeal court Decision pdf
 
Judgment date: 12.07.2005
Court name: Cour de Cassation
Court town: Paris
Parties: CNPA/ SPEA - Syndicat des Professionnels Européens de l'Automobile
Decision: Last instance pdf
 
Judgment date: 12.07.2005
Court name: Cour de Cassation
Court town: Paris
Parties: SPEA - Syndicat des Professionnels Européens de l'Automobile / Renault/Peugeot
Decision: Last instance pdf
 
Judgment date: 28.06.2005
Court name: Cour de Cassation
Court town: Paris
Parties: Garage Gremeau SA / DaimlerChrysler France SA
Decision: Last Instance - Judgment & Addendum pdf
 
Judgment date: 15.06.2005
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: Automobiles de Gap et des Alpes SA, Martin-Prevel Hervé / Automobiles Citroën SA
Decision: Appeal pdf
 
Judgment date: 08.06.2005
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: LCJ Diffusion SA / La Roche Posay SA & Cosmétique Active France SA
Decision: Appeal Court Decision pdf
 
Judgment date: 08.06.2005
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: LCJ Diffusion SA / La Roche Posay SA & Cosmétique Active France SA
Decision: Appeal Court Decision pdf
 
Judgment date: 24.05.2005
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: Digitechnic SARL
Decision: Appeal pdf
 
Judgment date: 12.04.2005
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: Export Press France / NMPP et al.
Decision: Appeal pdf
 
Judgment date: 12.04.2005
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: France Telecom SA & SFR / ETNA France
Decision: Appeal pdf
 
Judgment date: 02.03.2005
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: Kitch Moto SARL / Suzuki France SA
Decision: Appeal  pdf
 
Judgment date: 22.02.2005
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: JC Decaux / Clear Channel France
Decision: Appeal  pdf
 
Judgment date: 04.02.2005
Court name: TGI
Court town: Strasbourg
Parties: Kronenbourg/SARL JBEG
Decision: First Instance  pdf
 
Judgment date: 03.02.2005
Court name: TGI
Court town: Strasbourg
Parties: Kronenbourg/Café le Victor Hugo Sarl
Decision: First Instance  pdf
 
Judgment date: 26.01.2005 and 16.02.2005
Court name: Cour d'Appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: Volkswagen France / Bellevue Auto SA, Claude Petit & Raphaël Petit
Decision: Appeal Court Decision pdf
 
Judgment date: 12.09.2004
Court name: Cour d'appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: SPEA, Peugeot
Type of proceeding: Decision of a NCA
Sector: Motor vehicle sector
Decision: Appeal Court Decision pdf
 
Judgment date: 15.07.2004
Court name: Cour d'appel
Court town: Orleans
Parties: Toyota France SAS /SARL Autodiffusion 45
Decision: Appeal Court Decision pdf
 
Judgment date: 29.06.2004
Court name: Cour d'appel
Court town: Paris
Parties: SPEA - Syndicat des Professionnels Europens de l'Automobile
Renault SAS & GCR - Groupement des Concessionnaires Renault
Decision: Appeal Court Decision pdf
 
Judgment date: 07.06.2004
Court name: Tribunal des affaires de sécurité sociales de la Savoie
Court town: -
Parties: Meiller / CAPRIMKO
Decision: First Instance pdf
 
Judgment date: 03.05.2004
Court name: TGI
Court town: Strasbourg
Parties: Kronenbourg/SA J-C Chiriaux
Decision: First Instance  pdf
 
  
Back to index page