Facts may be exempted from the burden of proof by the law or by a pre-existing contract between the parties. Additionally, the court may consider certain facts proved by ‘taking judicial notice’, for example, matters of general knowledge. Some presumptions are taken as conclusively presumed, for example, if a statute provides this to be so and others may be rebutted, for example, the presumption that a person is sane.
The court must be convinced of a fact on the ‘balance of probabilities’ i.e. that it is at least 51% likely to be true as against 49% likely not to be true. Once a fact is proved on the balance of probabilities, it is taken to be established.
It is the general rule that a judge may not require the attendance of a witness, except in limited circumstances, but he can call a witness and recall a witness already called. By virtue of the rules which govern court procedure in Northern Ireland, the court has discretion to order any person to attend proceedings and produce a document.
If a party, usually through his lawyers, is permitted to call a particular witness to give evidence, his own lawyer will question the witness (this is called ‘evidence-in-chief’) and then the other party’s lawyer will cross-examine the witness. The Judge may ask questions of the witness and he will invite the lawyers, to follow up, if they wish, on anything that arises from what he has asked.
In certain cases, for example, where a witness is to attend a hearing in private, the court’s permission must be sought before the witness can be officially summoned to attend. Otherwise, the court has no control over which witnesses are called to give evidence although it may impose costs penalties on parties which call unnecessary witnesses.
The main method of proof is by oral testimony. Written testimony, such as reports from an expert, and documentary evidence, such as maps, may also be used.
The principal means is proof is by oral evidence of the parties
and their witnesses. The evidence of expert witnesses, for example,
doctors and engineers, may be taken from a written report by agreement.
The witness may then be questioned on particular points. Court rules
in Northern Ireland restrict the number of expert witnesses who
may give oral evidence to two medical experts and one other expert.
Maps and documents may also be used as evidence and their authenticity must be proved to the court’s satisfaction. Additionally, the court may wish to go to a scene or look at an actual item if it feels that doing so has some probative value.
It is always a matter for the court to decide what weight to attach to any particular piece of evidence.
There is a presumption that facts will be proved orally and in open court.
A competent witness who has been summoned to give evidence is obliged to appear at the hearing and failure to do so is contempt of court.
A party may claim ‘privilege’ from having to give evidence on the grounds of the existence of a legal professional relationship; self- incrimination of him or his spouse; public interest and administration of justice. There are other forms of privilege which are guaranteed by statute e.g. diplomatic privilege. Also, there is discretionary privilege, for example, in relation to information given in confidence.
Yes. A witness would be guilty of contempt of court if he failed to appear having been duly served with a witness summons or ‘subpoena’. The Judge could then impose a fine or period of imprisonment and require the witness to purge the contempt by attending and giving evidence.
Capacity is the general criterion for giving evidence. A person is considered to be capable of given evidence unless he is incapable of understanding the duty imposed by the oath due to infancy or, for example, insanity; he is the judge in the case or he is able to claim privilege.
The role of the parties, usually represented by lawyers (although
there is provision to represent oneself) is to present evidence
to the court to prove their case on the balance of the probabilities.
The Judge acts as umpire to ensure the questioning of witnesses
is fair, lawful and relevant to the points at issue in the case.
The Judge can question the witnesses himself but will allow the
parties’ lawyers to pursue anything that arises from the witness
in response to his questions.
Some limited use is now made, for example in the High Court in Belfast, to facilitate expert evidence via video link where the expert cannot readily come from another jurisdiction.
The court does not have a general discretion to exclude evidence that has been obtained unfairly. Evidence may only be excluded where there is statututory authority to do so or where it is struck from the record because it is scandalous or an abuse of process.
Yes, parties to a case may give evidence on their own behalf.
Last update: 17-08-2004